"Everything was in stark and dreadful contrast with the trivial crises and counterfeit emotions of Hollywood, and I returned to England deeply moved and emotionally worn out"
About this Quote
Hollywood gets dismissed here not as a place, but as a machine for manufacturing feeling on demand. Forester’s phrasing is doing two jobs at once: “stark and dreadful contrast” signals he has just encountered something real in the old, hard sense - suffering with consequences, not plot beats - while “trivial crises and counterfeit emotions” turns the film capital into a moral counterfeiters’ district, stamping cheap currency that only looks like experience.
The intent isn’t simply to sneer at actors or studios. It’s to defend a writer’s authority in an era when cinema was colonizing public imagination, teaching audiences what fear, romance, heroism, and grief are supposed to look like. Forester implies that Hollywood doesn’t just distract; it trains people to misrecognize reality. “Counterfeit” is the key word: the problem isn’t that the emotions are small, but that they’re forged - convincing enough to circulate, hollow enough to collapse under contact with actual catastrophe.
Context matters. Forester, best known for the Hornblower novels, wrote in the shadow of world war and empire’s attrition. Against that backdrop, Hollywood’s “crises” read like rehearsal, safely reversible, engineered for catharsis rather than reckoning. The final clause - “returned to England deeply moved and emotionally worn out” - is also a self-portrait of credibility: he comes back not entertained or enlightened, but depleted. It’s a quiet assertion that real events exact a cost, and that cost is the difference between art that illuminates reality and spectacle that merely imitates its surface.
The intent isn’t simply to sneer at actors or studios. It’s to defend a writer’s authority in an era when cinema was colonizing public imagination, teaching audiences what fear, romance, heroism, and grief are supposed to look like. Forester implies that Hollywood doesn’t just distract; it trains people to misrecognize reality. “Counterfeit” is the key word: the problem isn’t that the emotions are small, but that they’re forged - convincing enough to circulate, hollow enough to collapse under contact with actual catastrophe.
Context matters. Forester, best known for the Hornblower novels, wrote in the shadow of world war and empire’s attrition. Against that backdrop, Hollywood’s “crises” read like rehearsal, safely reversible, engineered for catharsis rather than reckoning. The final clause - “returned to England deeply moved and emotionally worn out” - is also a self-portrait of credibility: he comes back not entertained or enlightened, but depleted. It’s a quiet assertion that real events exact a cost, and that cost is the difference between art that illuminates reality and spectacle that merely imitates its surface.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by S. Forester
Add to List

