"Evolution is true, it happens, it is the way the world is, and we too are one of its products. This does not mean that evolution does not have metaphysical implications; I remain convinced that this is the case"
About this Quote
Conway Morris is doing something that scientists rarely get credit for: drawing a hard boundary and then deliberately leaning over it. The opening is blunt, almost defensive in its repetition - "true", "it happens", "the way the world is" - as if he is anticipating the tired culture-war move where evolution is treated as a belief system to be accepted or rejected. He plants the flag: evolution is descriptive fact, not a philosophical preference, and humans are not exempt.
Then comes the pivot that gives the quote its charge. By insisting that evolution can carry "metaphysical implications", he refuses the common trade: accept Darwin, abandon meaning. The subtext is aimed at two audiences at once. To religious skeptics of evolution, he's saying: stop arguing with the data; it isn't going away. To strict materialists, he's saying: don't smuggle your own metaphysics in under the label of "science" and pretend it's neutral.
Context matters because Conway Morris has long been associated with the idea of convergent evolution - that similar solutions repeatedly arise, suggesting constraints and, to some, a kind of directionality. So when he says he's "convinced" about metaphysical implications, he's not offering a lab result; he's framing an interpretive stance that rides on patterns he thinks nature keeps revealing. The rhetorical strategy is careful: evolution stays intact, but the existential story we tell about it remains contested, and he wants a seat at that table without surrendering scientific credibility.
Then comes the pivot that gives the quote its charge. By insisting that evolution can carry "metaphysical implications", he refuses the common trade: accept Darwin, abandon meaning. The subtext is aimed at two audiences at once. To religious skeptics of evolution, he's saying: stop arguing with the data; it isn't going away. To strict materialists, he's saying: don't smuggle your own metaphysics in under the label of "science" and pretend it's neutral.
Context matters because Conway Morris has long been associated with the idea of convergent evolution - that similar solutions repeatedly arise, suggesting constraints and, to some, a kind of directionality. So when he says he's "convinced" about metaphysical implications, he's not offering a lab result; he's framing an interpretive stance that rides on patterns he thinks nature keeps revealing. The rhetorical strategy is careful: evolution stays intact, but the existential story we tell about it remains contested, and he wants a seat at that table without surrendering scientific credibility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Simon
Add to List



