"Facts, according to my ideas, are merely the elements of truths, and not the truths themselves; of all matters there are none so utterly useless by themselves as your mere matters of fact"
About this Quote
Mayhew is picking a fight with the Victorian cult of measurement: the belief that if you can count it, you can understand it. His opening move is almost pedantic - facts are "elements" of truth, not truth - but the sting lands in the second clause, where he dismisses "mere matters of fact" as "utterly useless by themselves". It reads like an argument against the spreadsheet mindset before spreadsheets existed: data without interpretation is just noise dressed up as authority.
The intent is defensive and aggressive at once. As a journalist who made his name documenting London labor and poverty, Mayhew knew that raw observation can be weaponized. Enumerating wages, rents, arrests, or bread prices can create the illusion of neutrality while smuggling in a verdict: the poor are a problem to be managed, not people to be understood. By separating facts from truths, he’s also separating information from meaning - insisting that the reporter’s job isn’t simply to collect, but to connect, to show causation, structure, and lived consequence.
The subtext is a warning about moral laziness. "Mere matters of fact" lets institutions avoid responsibility: if the numbers are grim, the numbers are to blame. Mayhew pushes back against that convenient fatalism. His phrasing also flatters the reader’s intelligence - "according to my ideas" signals a personal credo, then dares you to consider whether your own reliance on facts has become a way of dodging harder truths.
In an era obsessed with statistics, his line still needles: facts are ingredients; truth is the meal.
The intent is defensive and aggressive at once. As a journalist who made his name documenting London labor and poverty, Mayhew knew that raw observation can be weaponized. Enumerating wages, rents, arrests, or bread prices can create the illusion of neutrality while smuggling in a verdict: the poor are a problem to be managed, not people to be understood. By separating facts from truths, he’s also separating information from meaning - insisting that the reporter’s job isn’t simply to collect, but to connect, to show causation, structure, and lived consequence.
The subtext is a warning about moral laziness. "Mere matters of fact" lets institutions avoid responsibility: if the numbers are grim, the numbers are to blame. Mayhew pushes back against that convenient fatalism. His phrasing also flatters the reader’s intelligence - "according to my ideas" signals a personal credo, then dares you to consider whether your own reliance on facts has become a way of dodging harder truths.
In an era obsessed with statistics, his line still needles: facts are ingredients; truth is the meal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List









