"Faith is an island in the setting sun, But proof is the bottom line for everyone"
About this Quote
An island at sunset is gorgeous, solitary, and doomed to darkness. Paul Simon picks that image because it lets faith feel both romantic and vulnerable: something you can stand on, yes, but also something surrounded, shrinking, and partially lit by a light that’s leaving. It’s not an attack line so much as a quiet admission that belief often lives in the late-day glow of feeling and memory, not in the harsh noon of verification.
Then he lands the other shoe with corporate bluntness: “the bottom line.” That phrase is accountant-speak, the language of budgets, contracts, and skeptics who don’t care how moving your story is if it doesn’t add up. The couplet stages a collision between the private lyricism of belief and the public demand for receipts. Even “everyone” is doing work here: Simon isn’t describing a niche of rationalists; he’s saying the proof-hunger is the default setting of modern life, a cultural gravity you don’t easily opt out of.
The intent feels less like preaching and more like reporting from inside a tension his songs return to again and again: spirituality as a human need, and doubt as a social condition. In a late-20th-century America increasingly shaped by science-talk, litigation, and consumer metrics, faith can still be beautiful - but it has to justify itself in a world that audits meaning. The genius is the balance: he makes the believer sympathetic, then reminds you why sympathy doesn’t count as evidence.
Then he lands the other shoe with corporate bluntness: “the bottom line.” That phrase is accountant-speak, the language of budgets, contracts, and skeptics who don’t care how moving your story is if it doesn’t add up. The couplet stages a collision between the private lyricism of belief and the public demand for receipts. Even “everyone” is doing work here: Simon isn’t describing a niche of rationalists; he’s saying the proof-hunger is the default setting of modern life, a cultural gravity you don’t easily opt out of.
The intent feels less like preaching and more like reporting from inside a tension his songs return to again and again: spirituality as a human need, and doubt as a social condition. In a late-20th-century America increasingly shaped by science-talk, litigation, and consumer metrics, faith can still be beautiful - but it has to justify itself in a world that audits meaning. The genius is the balance: he makes the believer sympathetic, then reminds you why sympathy doesn’t count as evidence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List







