"Faith is not contrary to reason"
About this Quote
“Faith is not contrary to reason” is a quiet provocation dressed up as reassurance. Sherwood Eddy isn’t picking a side in the old cage match of belief versus logic; he’s trying to dissolve the ring. As an author and prominent Christian social activist in the early 20th century, Eddy wrote in an era when modern science, higher biblical criticism, and industrial-age skepticism were pressuring religious certainty from all sides. The line reads like a strategic bridge for readers who wanted to keep their intellect without forfeiting their spirituality.
The intent is defensive, but not timid. Eddy is reclaiming reason as something faith can inhabit rather than fear. The subtext: if your faith feels irrational, you’ve been sold the wrong version of both faith and reason. He’s pushing back against two caricatures at once - the anti-intellectual piety that treats doubt as treason, and the smug rationalism that equates meaning with measurability. In Eddy’s framing, reason isn’t a guillotine; it’s a tool, and faith isn’t a substitute for thinking so much as a wager about what thinking can’t settle completely.
What makes the sentence work is its restraint. It doesn’t say faith is proved by reason, which would collapse faith into math. It simply denies the alleged contradiction. That’s rhetorically shrewd: Eddy lowers the temperature, invites the educated skeptic closer, and suggests that the real conflict isn’t between faith and reason, but between certainty and humility.
The intent is defensive, but not timid. Eddy is reclaiming reason as something faith can inhabit rather than fear. The subtext: if your faith feels irrational, you’ve been sold the wrong version of both faith and reason. He’s pushing back against two caricatures at once - the anti-intellectual piety that treats doubt as treason, and the smug rationalism that equates meaning with measurability. In Eddy’s framing, reason isn’t a guillotine; it’s a tool, and faith isn’t a substitute for thinking so much as a wager about what thinking can’t settle completely.
What makes the sentence work is its restraint. It doesn’t say faith is proved by reason, which would collapse faith into math. It simply denies the alleged contradiction. That’s rhetorically shrewd: Eddy lowers the temperature, invites the educated skeptic closer, and suggests that the real conflict isn’t between faith and reason, but between certainty and humility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Sherwood
Add to List






