"Falsehoods not only disagree with truths, but usually quarrel among themselves"
About this Quote
Webster’s line lands with the cold confidence of a courtroom closer: it doesn’t merely condemn lying as immoral, it frames it as structurally unstable. “Falsehoods” are not just wrong; they’re bad at teamwork. Truth, in this formulation, is coherent and mutually reinforcing, while lies proliferate like rival stories fighting for dominance. The verb choices do the work. “Disagree” sounds polite, almost parliamentary, but “quarrel” turns the second half into a brawl. Webster is smuggling in an argument about systems: truth forms a usable public reality; falsehoods create a noisy, self-canceling mess.
The intent is practical, not pious. As a statesman and lawyer in a young republic obsessed with legitimacy, Webster is warning that deception doesn’t just mislead an opponent; it corrodes the liar’s own case over time. One lie requires auxiliary lies, then explanations for those lies, and soon you’re not defending a position so much as managing an internal civil war of narratives. That’s why the line feels modern: it anticipates the way conspiracies fracture into factions, each improvising new “facts” to plug old holes.
Subtextually, Webster is elevating truth into a political technology. In democratic life, where persuasion replaces coercion, credibility is currency. His point is that falsehoods spend fast and then default, because they can’t reconcile with each other across witnesses, records, and memory. The quarrel is the tell.
The intent is practical, not pious. As a statesman and lawyer in a young republic obsessed with legitimacy, Webster is warning that deception doesn’t just mislead an opponent; it corrodes the liar’s own case over time. One lie requires auxiliary lies, then explanations for those lies, and soon you’re not defending a position so much as managing an internal civil war of narratives. That’s why the line feels modern: it anticipates the way conspiracies fracture into factions, each improvising new “facts” to plug old holes.
Subtextually, Webster is elevating truth into a political technology. In democratic life, where persuasion replaces coercion, credibility is currency. His point is that falsehoods spend fast and then default, because they can’t reconcile with each other across witnesses, records, and memory. The quarrel is the tell.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Daniel
Add to List












