"Far more thought and care go into the composition of any prominent ad in a newspaper or magazine than go into the writing of their features and editorials"
About this Quote
McLuhan’s barb lands because it flatters and indicts the reader at the same time: you think you’re consuming “serious” civic information, but the real intellectual labor is being spent on the machinery that sells you things. Coming from the theorist who taught a generation to see media as environments, not neutral pipelines, the line is less a complaint about lazy journalists than a diagnosis of where power concentrates.
The intent is to re-rank cultural prestige. Editorials and features posture as the newspaper’s brain; McLuhan argues the ad is the paper’s nervous system, tuned with ruthless precision to attention, desire, and behavior. Ads get A/B-tested before we had a name for it; they’re crafted by committees, vetted by lawyers, sharpened by research. Meanwhile, the “content” often runs on deadlines, habit, and inherited forms. He’s pointing at asymmetry: in a commercial media ecosystem, persuasion is better funded than explanation.
The subtext is even sharper: advertising isn’t an interruption to the medium, it’s the medium’s underlying purpose. If the economic engine is selling audiences to advertisers, then the most “prominent” ad is the publication’s most consequential text. Everything else becomes surround sound, a mood-setter that keeps you in the right frame of mind to be marketed to.
Context matters: mid-century mass media, when television and glossy magazines were perfecting the art of mass persuasion. McLuhan is warning that the real editorial line is written in copy and layout, not in opinion columns - and that modern literacy means learning to read the sales pitch as the central cultural document.
The intent is to re-rank cultural prestige. Editorials and features posture as the newspaper’s brain; McLuhan argues the ad is the paper’s nervous system, tuned with ruthless precision to attention, desire, and behavior. Ads get A/B-tested before we had a name for it; they’re crafted by committees, vetted by lawyers, sharpened by research. Meanwhile, the “content” often runs on deadlines, habit, and inherited forms. He’s pointing at asymmetry: in a commercial media ecosystem, persuasion is better funded than explanation.
The subtext is even sharper: advertising isn’t an interruption to the medium, it’s the medium’s underlying purpose. If the economic engine is selling audiences to advertisers, then the most “prominent” ad is the publication’s most consequential text. Everything else becomes surround sound, a mood-setter that keeps you in the right frame of mind to be marketed to.
Context matters: mid-century mass media, when television and glossy magazines were perfecting the art of mass persuasion. McLuhan is warning that the real editorial line is written in copy and layout, not in opinion columns - and that modern literacy means learning to read the sales pitch as the central cultural document.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Marshall
Add to List
