"Farming as we do it is hunting, and in the sea we act like barbarians"
About this Quote
Cousteau lands the insult where it hurts: on the comforting stories modern societies tell themselves about “food production.” By calling farming “hunting,” he collapses a moral hierarchy that usually paints agriculture as settled, civilized, and therefore ethically cleaner than killing animals. The line is engineered to sting because it reframes the supermarket as a masked version of the chase: extraction, control, and death, just outsourced and mechanized.
Then he pivots to the ocean and drops the word “barbarians,” a term loaded with empire-era smugness. Cousteau uses it deliberately, not to flatter land-based “civilization,” but to expose how quickly that veneer peels off once the victim is out of sight and out of voice. On land, there are fences, quotas, and optics. At sea, especially in the mid-20th century boom of industrial fishing, the scale becomes abstract: nets that scrape the bottom, bycatch treated as collateral, entire ecosystems converted into tonnage. The barbarism isn’t passion; it’s procedure.
The subtext is classic Cousteau: awe as a moral instrument. As an explorer who helped make the underwater world visible to mass audiences, he’s indicting a blindness problem. You can’t care about what you can’t see, and modern extraction depends on that invisibility. The intent isn’t anti-farming romanticism so much as an ecological reality check: if we want the sea to remain a world, not a mine, we have to admit what our methods actually are.
Then he pivots to the ocean and drops the word “barbarians,” a term loaded with empire-era smugness. Cousteau uses it deliberately, not to flatter land-based “civilization,” but to expose how quickly that veneer peels off once the victim is out of sight and out of voice. On land, there are fences, quotas, and optics. At sea, especially in the mid-20th century boom of industrial fishing, the scale becomes abstract: nets that scrape the bottom, bycatch treated as collateral, entire ecosystems converted into tonnage. The barbarism isn’t passion; it’s procedure.
The subtext is classic Cousteau: awe as a moral instrument. As an explorer who helped make the underwater world visible to mass audiences, he’s indicting a blindness problem. You can’t care about what you can’t see, and modern extraction depends on that invisibility. The intent isn’t anti-farming romanticism so much as an ecological reality check: if we want the sea to remain a world, not a mine, we have to admit what our methods actually are.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ocean & Sea |
|---|
More Quotes by Jacques
Add to List





