"Fate is nothing but the deeds committed in a prior state of existence"
About this Quote
Emerson takes a word people use to dodge responsibility and snaps it back into the moral order. "Fate" usually arrives as a fog: a bad marriage, a busted economy, a body that betrays you. By insisting it is "nothing but the deeds committed in a prior state of existence", he reframes destiny as delayed accountability. The line has the clean, prosecutorial bite of an aphorism: it doesn’t argue, it sentences.
The intent is less metaphysical than disciplinary. Emerson is writing in a 19th-century America drunk on possibility yet still haunted by inherited hierarchies, Puritan guilt, and the new secular temptation to treat life as pure chance. He wants a universe where consequences stick, where your circumstances aren’t a cosmic coin flip but a ledger. "Prior state of existence" borrows the aroma of reincarnation without fully committing to Eastern doctrine; it’s a strategic ambiguity that lets him smuggle in karmic logic while staying legible to Christian-trained readers. You don’t need literal past lives for the idea to land. Your "prior state" can be yesterday’s habit, your family’s history, your nation’s sins.
Subtext: stop romanticizing powerlessness. Emerson’s self-reliance often gets marketed as inspirational wallpaper, but here it’s sterner. Fate becomes the long shadow of action, a way of saying: you are not trapped by destiny; you are trapped by patterns you (or your predecessors) set in motion. It works because it flatters and accuses at once, granting agency even as it denies excuses.
The intent is less metaphysical than disciplinary. Emerson is writing in a 19th-century America drunk on possibility yet still haunted by inherited hierarchies, Puritan guilt, and the new secular temptation to treat life as pure chance. He wants a universe where consequences stick, where your circumstances aren’t a cosmic coin flip but a ledger. "Prior state of existence" borrows the aroma of reincarnation without fully committing to Eastern doctrine; it’s a strategic ambiguity that lets him smuggle in karmic logic while staying legible to Christian-trained readers. You don’t need literal past lives for the idea to land. Your "prior state" can be yesterday’s habit, your family’s history, your nation’s sins.
Subtext: stop romanticizing powerlessness. Emerson’s self-reliance often gets marketed as inspirational wallpaper, but here it’s sterner. Fate becomes the long shadow of action, a way of saying: you are not trapped by destiny; you are trapped by patterns you (or your predecessors) set in motion. It works because it flatters and accuses at once, granting agency even as it denies excuses.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List







