"Fate, or some mysterious force, can put the finger on you or me, for no good reason at all"
About this Quote
There is a cold comfort in blaming the universe, and Martin Goldsmith refuses to make it warm. "Fate, or some mysterious force" is phrased like a shrug with teeth: not a grand mythic Destiny, not a neat religious plan, just a vague agency we reach for when the world stops making moral sense. The verb choice is the gut punch. Fate doesnt "choose" or "call"; it "can put the finger on you", a gesture that feels accusatory, almost bureaucratic, like being singled out in a lineup. It captures that specific terror of randomness: not merely that bad things happen, but that they happen with the intimacy of being personally selected.
"No good reason at all" lands as a rebuke to the stories we tell to survive. People crave causality because causality implies control: work hard, be careful, be virtuous, and youll be spared. Goldsmith punctures that bargain. The line also carries an ethical warning: if misfortune can strike arbitrarily, then the ease with which we explain other peoples suffering as deserved is revealed as self-protective fiction.
Contextually, Goldsmiths writing often circles memory, loss, and the lingering aftershocks of historical catastrophe. This sentence feels informed by that terrain: the lived knowledge that history doesnt distribute pain according to merit. The intent isnt nihilism; its clarity. It demands a different response to vulnerability: less smugness, more solidarity, because the finger can land anywhere.
"No good reason at all" lands as a rebuke to the stories we tell to survive. People crave causality because causality implies control: work hard, be careful, be virtuous, and youll be spared. Goldsmith punctures that bargain. The line also carries an ethical warning: if misfortune can strike arbitrarily, then the ease with which we explain other peoples suffering as deserved is revealed as self-protective fiction.
Contextually, Goldsmiths writing often circles memory, loss, and the lingering aftershocks of historical catastrophe. This sentence feels informed by that terrain: the lived knowledge that history doesnt distribute pain according to merit. The intent isnt nihilism; its clarity. It demands a different response to vulnerability: less smugness, more solidarity, because the finger can land anywhere.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Martin
Add to List







