"Field of Dreams is probably our generation's It's A Wonderful Life"
About this Quote
Costner is doing more than praising a beloved baseball movie; he’s lobbying for its canonization. By calling Field of Dreams “our generation’s It’s a Wonderful Life,” he borrows one of America’s safest cultural currencies: the idea of a film that outgrows its release, turns into ritual, and becomes a shorthand for decency. That comparison is strategic because it skips the fussy argument about craft and goes straight to legacy. You don’t debate It’s a Wonderful Life; you inherit it.
The subtext is that Field of Dreams isn’t really about baseball any more than Capra’s film is really about banking. Both use a familiar, wholesome setting to smuggle in something more volatile: regret, unrealized lives, and the fantasy that a single act of faith can repair time. Costner’s line gently frames the movie as an emotional utility: not “a great sports film,” but a cultural comfort object that people reach for when they need reassurance about family, community, and the possibility of reconciliation.
There’s also a savvy generational claim embedded in “our.” It positions late-20th-century sentimental masculinity as worthy of the same reverence granted to mid-century moral uplift. In an era that often treats earnestness as naive, Costner is defending sincerity as a legitimate aesthetic choice. The intent isn’t irony; it’s permission. He’s telling audiences that tearful wish-fulfillment, handled with conviction, can be as enduring as any prestige classic.
The subtext is that Field of Dreams isn’t really about baseball any more than Capra’s film is really about banking. Both use a familiar, wholesome setting to smuggle in something more volatile: regret, unrealized lives, and the fantasy that a single act of faith can repair time. Costner’s line gently frames the movie as an emotional utility: not “a great sports film,” but a cultural comfort object that people reach for when they need reassurance about family, community, and the possibility of reconciliation.
There’s also a savvy generational claim embedded in “our.” It positions late-20th-century sentimental masculinity as worthy of the same reverence granted to mid-century moral uplift. In an era that often treats earnestness as naive, Costner is defending sincerity as a legitimate aesthetic choice. The intent isn’t irony; it’s permission. He’s telling audiences that tearful wish-fulfillment, handled with conviction, can be as enduring as any prestige classic.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Kevin
Add to List



