"Film music should have the same relationship to the film drama that somebody's piano playing in my living room has on the book I am reading"
About this Quote
Stravinsky’s line lands like a slap at the swollen heart-strings of Hollywood. He’s not arguing that music is unimportant; he’s insisting it’s fundamentally external. The image is domestic and faintly rude: you’re reading, trying to follow a plot, and someone is noodling at the piano nearby. It might be pleasant, it might be irritating, but it isn’t the book. That’s the point. Film drama, to Stravinsky, should stand on its own architecture of action, pacing, and image. Music that “explains” the story, telegraphs emotion, or supplies missing psychological plumbing is a kind of aesthetic crutch.
The subtext is bigger than cinema. This is Stravinsky the modernist, allergic to Romantic excess and suspicious of art that begs to be felt “correctly.” He spent a career arguing for discipline, clarity, and a separation between form and sentimentality. In that light, the quote reads as a rebuke to the Wagnerian idea of total artwork where music fuses with narrative to produce a single overpowering experience. Film scoring, in his view, too easily becomes manipulation: an invisible hand pushing the audience’s face toward the tear.
Context matters: Stravinsky lived through the rise of sound film and the golden age of lush, symphonic scores. He also flirted with film commissions and found the industry’s demands uncongenial. So the jab is personal as well as philosophical: a composer defending the autonomy of music by refusing cinema’s invitation to be a narrative servant. The provocation still stings because it forces a question: are we moved by the scene, or by the soundtrack telling us to be moved?
The subtext is bigger than cinema. This is Stravinsky the modernist, allergic to Romantic excess and suspicious of art that begs to be felt “correctly.” He spent a career arguing for discipline, clarity, and a separation between form and sentimentality. In that light, the quote reads as a rebuke to the Wagnerian idea of total artwork where music fuses with narrative to produce a single overpowering experience. Film scoring, in his view, too easily becomes manipulation: an invisible hand pushing the audience’s face toward the tear.
Context matters: Stravinsky lived through the rise of sound film and the golden age of lush, symphonic scores. He also flirted with film commissions and found the industry’s demands uncongenial. So the jab is personal as well as philosophical: a composer defending the autonomy of music by refusing cinema’s invitation to be a narrative servant. The provocation still stings because it forces a question: are we moved by the scene, or by the soundtrack telling us to be moved?
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Igor
Add to List
