"First, he must hold rational values, and to do this he must be a thinker"
About this Quote
The line lands like a gatekeeper sentence, and that is partly the point. Bernstein isn’t praising “thinking” in the soft, motivational-poster sense; he’s drawing a hard boundary around what counts as a proper moral life. “Rational values” are treated as the only legitimate currency, and the phrase “to do this he must be a thinker” makes cognition not just useful but mandatory. The rhetoric is deliberately hierarchical: values sit above impulses, habits, traditions, and inherited loyalties, and the person who won’t or can’t think is quietly demoted from full moral agency.
The subtext is a rebuke to cultural default settings. It pushes against the idea that values can be absorbed passively from family, religion, or social consensus and still be “held” in any meaningful way. “Hold” here implies active maintenance: you keep values by understanding their roots, checking their coherence, and defending them against contradiction. That’s a very Objectivist move (Bernstein is associated with Ayn Rand’s tradition): morality as a system you can justify, not a set of feelings you can report.
Context matters because the sentence is also a political warning disguised as ethics. If rational values require thinkers, then a society that discourages thinking - through conformity, anti-intellectualism, or emotional primacy - doesn’t just produce bad opinions; it produces bad character. The sharpness is intentional: it flatters the reader into the identity of “thinker,” while pressuring them to earn it. It’s philosophy as a call to self-selection, not comfort.
The subtext is a rebuke to cultural default settings. It pushes against the idea that values can be absorbed passively from family, religion, or social consensus and still be “held” in any meaningful way. “Hold” here implies active maintenance: you keep values by understanding their roots, checking their coherence, and defending them against contradiction. That’s a very Objectivist move (Bernstein is associated with Ayn Rand’s tradition): morality as a system you can justify, not a set of feelings you can report.
Context matters because the sentence is also a political warning disguised as ethics. If rational values require thinkers, then a society that discourages thinking - through conformity, anti-intellectualism, or emotional primacy - doesn’t just produce bad opinions; it produces bad character. The sharpness is intentional: it flatters the reader into the identity of “thinker,” while pressuring them to earn it. It’s philosophy as a call to self-selection, not comfort.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Andrew
Add to List
