"Football is a game designed to keep coal miners off the streets"
About this Quote
Breslin’s line lands like a wisecrack and then keeps cutting after you laugh. Calling football “designed” to keep coal miners off the streets frames the sport not as an organic pastime but as social engineering: a safety valve built for an industrial society that feared what its exhausted, underpaid workers might do with unstructured anger and free time. The phrase “off the streets” is the tell. Streets are where crowds form, where grievances become visible, where power gets challenged. Put the men in the stands, put them in front of the TV, give them a tribe and a weekly ritual, and you’ve redirected volatility into scheduled, monetized catharsis.
Coal miners are not a random emblem. They’re the archetype of brutal labor and collective bargaining power: historically organized, historically combustible, historically ignored until they stop working. Breslin’s subtext is that football can be a culturally sanctioned outlet for the same impulses that might otherwise fuel labor agitation - aggression, solidarity, loyalty, endurance. It’s not that fans are dupes; it’s that a system can benefit when identification replaces confrontation. Root for a team, not a union. Argue about a coach, not a boss.
The humor is the hook, but the cynicism is the point: bread and circuses, American edition, with helmets. Breslin, a columnist who loved the city and distrusted its machinery, is suggesting the game’s greatness and its utility to power can be true at the same time.
Coal miners are not a random emblem. They’re the archetype of brutal labor and collective bargaining power: historically organized, historically combustible, historically ignored until they stop working. Breslin’s subtext is that football can be a culturally sanctioned outlet for the same impulses that might otherwise fuel labor agitation - aggression, solidarity, loyalty, endurance. It’s not that fans are dupes; it’s that a system can benefit when identification replaces confrontation. Root for a team, not a union. Argue about a coach, not a boss.
The humor is the hook, but the cynicism is the point: bread and circuses, American edition, with helmets. Breslin, a columnist who loved the city and distrusted its machinery, is suggesting the game’s greatness and its utility to power can be true at the same time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Jimmy
Add to List






