"For every benefit you receive a tax is levied"
About this Quote
Emerson’s line lands like a moral invoice slipped under the door: whatever you think you’ve “gotten away with” will be settled, quietly but inevitably. The genius is the word tax. It’s not divine thunder or melodramatic punishment; it’s accounting. Ordinary, impersonal, unavoidable. By framing consequence as a levy, Emerson turns ethics into economics and makes responsibility feel less like a sermon than a system.
The specific intent is corrective. Emerson, the American apostle of self-reliance, is warning against the fantasy of costless gain: the belief that advantage can be pocketed without some counterweight. In his worldview, the universe has a built-in ledger. Benefits are real, but they’re never free. The price might be time, integrity, attention, dependence, or the slow erosion of character that comes from taking shortcuts. “Tax” suggests you don’t always choose when or how payment arrives; you just find yourself paying.
The subtext is also a critique of entitlement. Emerson is pressing back against a culture of acquisition (already accelerating in 19th-century America) by insisting that every uplift creates an obligation. Gift implies duty. Success implies scrutiny. Even pleasure implies a hangover of some kind, if not physical then moral.
Context matters: Emerson is writing in an era of market revolution and rising individualism, where “getting ahead” is becoming a civic religion. He doesn’t deny ambition; he disciplines it. The line is a compact Transcendentalist check on American optimism, reminding readers that the cosmos, unlike a con man’s scheme, always collects.
The specific intent is corrective. Emerson, the American apostle of self-reliance, is warning against the fantasy of costless gain: the belief that advantage can be pocketed without some counterweight. In his worldview, the universe has a built-in ledger. Benefits are real, but they’re never free. The price might be time, integrity, attention, dependence, or the slow erosion of character that comes from taking shortcuts. “Tax” suggests you don’t always choose when or how payment arrives; you just find yourself paying.
The subtext is also a critique of entitlement. Emerson is pressing back against a culture of acquisition (already accelerating in 19th-century America) by insisting that every uplift creates an obligation. Gift implies duty. Success implies scrutiny. Even pleasure implies a hangover of some kind, if not physical then moral.
Context matters: Emerson is writing in an era of market revolution and rising individualism, where “getting ahead” is becoming a civic religion. He doesn’t deny ambition; he disciplines it. The line is a compact Transcendentalist check on American optimism, reminding readers that the cosmos, unlike a con man’s scheme, always collects.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List





