"For if any man who never saw fire proved by satisfactory arguments that fire burns. His hearer's mind would never be satisfied, nor would he avoid the fire until he put his hand in it that he might learn by experiment what argument taught"
About this Quote
Bacon lands a gentle punch on the medieval faith in syllogisms: you can win the argument and still lose the lesson. The image is almost comic - a man who has never seen fire laying out airtight proofs that it burns - because it exposes a mismatch between intellectual certainty and bodily conviction. Logic can map the world, but it cant substitute for the sting that makes knowledge real.
The intent is polemical. Writing in a culture where authority and deduction often outranked observation, Bacon is staking out an early empirical credo: experience is not decoration; its the engine of assent. His phrasing stages a hierarchy. Argument can teach, but only experiment satisfies. The hearer isnt portrayed as stupid; hes human. Minds are sticky. We dont fully believe what we havent felt.
The subtext is also a warning about the social economy of expertise. A speaker can sound rigorous and still be untrustworthy if he lacks contact with the thing he describes. Bacon is quietly diagnosing how misinformation works long before the term existed: persuasive structure can mimic truth, and audiences will remain unconvinced - or worse, act recklessly - until reality imposes its own demonstration.
Context matters. Bacon, a 13th-century Franciscan, advocated mathematics, optics, and experiment at a time when learned disputation was a dominant academic sport. The line reads like an early manifesto for the laboratory mindset: knowledge is not merely argued into existence; it is tested, touched, and sometimes paid for in pain.
The intent is polemical. Writing in a culture where authority and deduction often outranked observation, Bacon is staking out an early empirical credo: experience is not decoration; its the engine of assent. His phrasing stages a hierarchy. Argument can teach, but only experiment satisfies. The hearer isnt portrayed as stupid; hes human. Minds are sticky. We dont fully believe what we havent felt.
The subtext is also a warning about the social economy of expertise. A speaker can sound rigorous and still be untrustworthy if he lacks contact with the thing he describes. Bacon is quietly diagnosing how misinformation works long before the term existed: persuasive structure can mimic truth, and audiences will remain unconvinced - or worse, act recklessly - until reality imposes its own demonstration.
Context matters. Bacon, a 13th-century Franciscan, advocated mathematics, optics, and experiment at a time when learned disputation was a dominant academic sport. The line reads like an early manifesto for the laboratory mindset: knowledge is not merely argued into existence; it is tested, touched, and sometimes paid for in pain.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by Roger
Add to List
