"For if you do, then shouldn't we blame the whole fraternity system? And if the whole fraternity system is guilty, then isn't this an indictment of our educational institutions in general? I put it to you, Greg - isn't this an indictment of our entire American society?"
About this Quote
A perfect parody of how outrage laundering works: start with one person doing something indefensible, then sprint up the ladder of abstraction until no one is responsible and everyone is implicated. Tim Matheson’s line (as the smugly “reasonable” Eric Stratton in National Lampoon’s Animal House) is less an argument than a performance of moral seriousness. It mimics the rhetoric of civic inquiry while using it to dodge consequences, turning a disciplinary hearing into a seminar on “society.”
The intent is tactical. By expanding the frame from an individual fraternity to “educational institutions” to “our entire American society,” he tries to make punishment feel both petty and impossible. If everything is to blame, then nothing can be meaningfully corrected here, today, in this room. The comic charge comes from that inflation: the pomp of “I put it to you” and the name-check (“Greg”) plays like courtroom gravitas, but it’s deployed to defend a house of chaotic privileged kids.
Subtext: this is elite self-protection dressed up as intellectual rigor. It’s the early-60s setting filtered through 1978 skepticism - a moment when institutions were both revered and distrusted, when “systemic critique” could be sincere politics or convenient cover. Animal House knows the difference and weaponizes it for laughs. Matheson nails the sweet spot of American hypocrisy: the ability to sound principled while bargaining for impunity.
The intent is tactical. By expanding the frame from an individual fraternity to “educational institutions” to “our entire American society,” he tries to make punishment feel both petty and impossible. If everything is to blame, then nothing can be meaningfully corrected here, today, in this room. The comic charge comes from that inflation: the pomp of “I put it to you” and the name-check (“Greg”) plays like courtroom gravitas, but it’s deployed to defend a house of chaotic privileged kids.
Subtext: this is elite self-protection dressed up as intellectual rigor. It’s the early-60s setting filtered through 1978 skepticism - a moment when institutions were both revered and distrusted, when “systemic critique” could be sincere politics or convenient cover. Animal House knows the difference and weaponizes it for laughs. Matheson nails the sweet spot of American hypocrisy: the ability to sound principled while bargaining for impunity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Tim
Add to List






