"For me archaeology is not a source of illustrations for written texts, but an independent source of historical information, with no less value and importance, sometimes more importance, that the written sources"
About this Quote
Rostovtzeff is drawing a hard boundary line against a laziness that still haunts the humanities: the habit of treating objects as stage props for stories we already believe. His insistence that archaeology is "independent" isn’t a polite disciplinary compliment; it’s a declaration of method. Written texts come with authors, audiences, censorship, prestige, and self-serving myth. They tell you what elites wanted remembered. A pot shard, a coin hoard, a city’s street grid, a layer of ash tells you what actually happened to bodies, trade, housing, and daily life when nobody was composing a narrative.
The subtext is a rebuke to text-first historians who use material culture as decorative confirmation. Rostovtzeff flips the hierarchy: sometimes the mute evidence is "more important" precisely because it can’t flatter itself. Archaeology catches the unlettered, the peripheral, and the accidental - the people and processes that rarely make it into archives. It also catches the gaps where archives fail: periods of upheaval, regions outside bureaucratic reach, moments where the record is intentionally destroyed or never produced.
Context matters. Writing across the early 20th century, Rostovtzeff helped shape social and economic history of the ancient world, when papyrology, numismatics, and large-scale excavation were rapidly expanding what historians could know beyond classical literary canons. His line reads like a manifesto for a more democratic past: history not as a curated bookshelf, but as a messier, wider ledger where walls and trash heaps get a vote.
The subtext is a rebuke to text-first historians who use material culture as decorative confirmation. Rostovtzeff flips the hierarchy: sometimes the mute evidence is "more important" precisely because it can’t flatter itself. Archaeology catches the unlettered, the peripheral, and the accidental - the people and processes that rarely make it into archives. It also catches the gaps where archives fail: periods of upheaval, regions outside bureaucratic reach, moments where the record is intentionally destroyed or never produced.
Context matters. Writing across the early 20th century, Rostovtzeff helped shape social and economic history of the ancient world, when papyrology, numismatics, and large-scale excavation were rapidly expanding what historians could know beyond classical literary canons. His line reads like a manifesto for a more democratic past: history not as a curated bookshelf, but as a messier, wider ledger where walls and trash heaps get a vote.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List





