"For me, as a beginning novelist, all other living writers form a control group for whom the world is a placebo"
About this Quote
Jealousy rarely sounds this funny, or this chemically precise. Nicholson Baker takes the soggy, self-important anguish of the “beginning novelist” and runs it through the language of clinical trials: control group, placebo, world. The joke lands because it’s both grandiose and humiliating. Grandiose because he casts his private insecurity as science; humiliating because the experiment is obviously rigged by ego.
The intent is a kind of preemptive self-defense. If you’re just starting out, other writers aren’t merely peers; they’re an entire alternative reality in which talent seems effortless and recognition feels inevitable. Baker’s twist is to deny them the “real” world altogether. They don’t truly get the full-strength dose of life, he implies; they’re living on sugar pills. That’s a petty, perfect fantasy: if they’re winning, it must be because the game is fake.
The subtext is less about contempt for other authors than a portrait of the novice’s paranoid math. Early ambition tends to treat literature as a zero-sum lab: every admired writer becomes evidence against your own prospects, every acclaimed novel a symptom of your insufficiency. By describing the world as a placebo for everyone else, he exposes how the mind tries to preserve its sense of specialness when it can’t yet prove it on the page.
Contextually, it’s Baker in mini: highbrow obsessiveness, sly self-mockery, and a refusal to romanticize the writer’s life. He makes the unflattering feeling legible without asking to be absolved for it. That’s why it works: it’s insecurity with a scalpel, not a violin.
The intent is a kind of preemptive self-defense. If you’re just starting out, other writers aren’t merely peers; they’re an entire alternative reality in which talent seems effortless and recognition feels inevitable. Baker’s twist is to deny them the “real” world altogether. They don’t truly get the full-strength dose of life, he implies; they’re living on sugar pills. That’s a petty, perfect fantasy: if they’re winning, it must be because the game is fake.
The subtext is less about contempt for other authors than a portrait of the novice’s paranoid math. Early ambition tends to treat literature as a zero-sum lab: every admired writer becomes evidence against your own prospects, every acclaimed novel a symptom of your insufficiency. By describing the world as a placebo for everyone else, he exposes how the mind tries to preserve its sense of specialness when it can’t yet prove it on the page.
Contextually, it’s Baker in mini: highbrow obsessiveness, sly self-mockery, and a refusal to romanticize the writer’s life. He makes the unflattering feeling legible without asking to be absolved for it. That’s why it works: it’s insecurity with a scalpel, not a violin.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Nicholson
Add to List
