"For purposes of action nothing is more useful than narrowness of thought combined with energy of will"
About this Quote
Efficiency has a dark secret: it loves blinders. Amiel’s line is less a pep talk than a diagnosis of how things actually get done in the world. “For purposes of action” is the tell. He’s carving off the realm of doing from the realm of understanding, then admitting that action often rewards the very traits contemplative minds distrust: narrowed focus and stubborn drive.
The phrasing sets up an uncomfortable chemistry. “Narrowness of thought” sounds like an insult, but Amiel pairs it with “energy of will,” turning a cognitive flaw into a practical advantage. The subtext is that deliberation, nuance, and self-critique can be luxuries that sabotage momentum. To act is to simplify: you pick one thread of the messy real and tug hard, ignoring the dozens you might be missing. That selective blindness becomes “useful” because it quiets doubt, mutes competing explanations, and shrinks moral complexity into a plan you can execute.
Context matters: Amiel was a 19th-century philosopher steeped in introspection, writing in an era that prized systems and certainties while modernity accelerated politics, industry, and ideology. He’s watching willpower outcompete wisdom, and he’s honest enough to say so. There’s irony here too: the sentence itself is lucidly nuanced about the utility of being un-nuanced.
It lands today because it describes how movements, startups, campaigns, and even personal reinventions succeed: not by comprehending everything, but by committing to one story and pushing it through resistance. The warning is embedded in the praise. Narrowness is productive, and that’s exactly what makes it dangerous.
The phrasing sets up an uncomfortable chemistry. “Narrowness of thought” sounds like an insult, but Amiel pairs it with “energy of will,” turning a cognitive flaw into a practical advantage. The subtext is that deliberation, nuance, and self-critique can be luxuries that sabotage momentum. To act is to simplify: you pick one thread of the messy real and tug hard, ignoring the dozens you might be missing. That selective blindness becomes “useful” because it quiets doubt, mutes competing explanations, and shrinks moral complexity into a plan you can execute.
Context matters: Amiel was a 19th-century philosopher steeped in introspection, writing in an era that prized systems and certainties while modernity accelerated politics, industry, and ideology. He’s watching willpower outcompete wisdom, and he’s honest enough to say so. There’s irony here too: the sentence itself is lucidly nuanced about the utility of being un-nuanced.
It lands today because it describes how movements, startups, campaigns, and even personal reinventions succeed: not by comprehending everything, but by committing to one story and pushing it through resistance. The warning is embedded in the praise. Narrowness is productive, and that’s exactly what makes it dangerous.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Discipline |
|---|
More Quotes by Henri
Add to List
