"For strange effects and extraordinary combinations we must go to life itself, which is always far more daring than any effort of the imagination"
About this Quote
Doyle’s line is a quiet rebuke to the romantic myth of the all-powerful imagination. Coming from a writer famous for clockwork plots and forensic cleverness, it lands with an extra twist: the man paid to invent “extraordinary combinations” is admitting that reality routinely outperforms the novelist’s contrivance. The brag here belongs not to art but to life, which doesn’t bother to make itself plausible.
The intent is partly aesthetic and partly epistemic. Doyle is arguing for a kind of realism that isn’t drab but flamboyant: coincidence, contradiction, and sheer human irrationality are not weaknesses in a story; they’re the baseline conditions of existence. Subtext: if a narrative feels “too weird,” that reaction says more about the audience’s craving for order than about the world’s actual shape. It’s also a defense of his own method. Sherlock Holmes is celebrated as the avatar of reason, yet the cases work because they’re fueled by messy motives, social pressures, and bizarre accidents. Holmes imposes pattern on chaos; Doyle reminds us the chaos is the natural state.
Context matters. Doyle wrote in an era enthralled by modernity’s shocks: new technologies, mass cities, imperial entanglements, sensational crimes reported as entertainment. “Extraordinary combinations” were not just literary flourishes; they were headlines. The quote flatters the reader’s appetite for the uncanny while insisting it doesn’t need to be manufactured. Life is already doing the wild stuff. The writer’s job is to notice it, shape it, and resist the temptation to tidy it into something less daring.
The intent is partly aesthetic and partly epistemic. Doyle is arguing for a kind of realism that isn’t drab but flamboyant: coincidence, contradiction, and sheer human irrationality are not weaknesses in a story; they’re the baseline conditions of existence. Subtext: if a narrative feels “too weird,” that reaction says more about the audience’s craving for order than about the world’s actual shape. It’s also a defense of his own method. Sherlock Holmes is celebrated as the avatar of reason, yet the cases work because they’re fueled by messy motives, social pressures, and bizarre accidents. Holmes imposes pattern on chaos; Doyle reminds us the chaos is the natural state.
Context matters. Doyle wrote in an era enthralled by modernity’s shocks: new technologies, mass cities, imperial entanglements, sensational crimes reported as entertainment. “Extraordinary combinations” were not just literary flourishes; they were headlines. The quote flatters the reader’s appetite for the uncanny while insisting it doesn’t need to be manufactured. Life is already doing the wild stuff. The writer’s job is to notice it, shape it, and resist the temptation to tidy it into something less daring.
Quote Details
| Topic | Life |
|---|
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List
