"Freud said that we are born as a tabula rasa. This is a model that simply is too superficial and inadequate"
About this Quote
Grof is picking a fight with psychology’s clean-room fantasy: the idea that a human arrives as blank paper, then culture and parenting do the writing. By invoking Freud, he’s not just disputing a detail in psychoanalytic history; he’s signaling that even the grand old architects of depth psychology still smuggled in a strangely shallow origin story. “Tabula rasa” becomes a rhetorical straw man for a wider professional habit: treating experience as something that starts at birth and stays comfortably biographical.
The jab lands because it’s aimed at what institutions can measure. A “blank slate” model flatters mainstream clinical practice: symptoms trace back to family dynamics, development, and identifiable events. It yields narratives that fit case notes, not necessarily consciousness. Grof, a key figure in transpersonal psychology and early psychedelic therapy research, is pushing for a psyche that arrives already crowded - with prenatal imprinting, perinatal trauma, archetypal material, and the kind of non-ordinary states that don’t behave like tidy memories.
“Superficial and inadequate” is doing strategic work. Superficial: it skims the surface of subjectivity, mistaking autobiography for the whole person. Inadequate: it fails pragmatically, because some experiences patients report - annihilation, rebirth, cosmic unity, ancestral scenes - don’t resolve when you only search the postnatal timeline. The subtext is a challenge to the field’s gatekeeping: if your model can’t metabolize what people actually experience in altered states, then the model isn’t scientific restraint; it’s professional defensiveness.
The jab lands because it’s aimed at what institutions can measure. A “blank slate” model flatters mainstream clinical practice: symptoms trace back to family dynamics, development, and identifiable events. It yields narratives that fit case notes, not necessarily consciousness. Grof, a key figure in transpersonal psychology and early psychedelic therapy research, is pushing for a psyche that arrives already crowded - with prenatal imprinting, perinatal trauma, archetypal material, and the kind of non-ordinary states that don’t behave like tidy memories.
“Superficial and inadequate” is doing strategic work. Superficial: it skims the surface of subjectivity, mistaking autobiography for the whole person. Inadequate: it fails pragmatically, because some experiences patients report - annihilation, rebirth, cosmic unity, ancestral scenes - don’t resolve when you only search the postnatal timeline. The subtext is a challenge to the field’s gatekeeping: if your model can’t metabolize what people actually experience in altered states, then the model isn’t scientific restraint; it’s professional defensiveness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Stanislav
Add to List





