"Friendship will not stand the strain of very much good advice for very long"
About this Quote
Friendship, Lynd suggests, is less a self-help project than a fragile truce between two egos. The line lands because it punctures a polite myth: that care equals correction. “Good advice” is the bait here - ostensibly benevolent, culturally rewarded - but Lynd treats it like a solvent. The strain isn’t that the advice is bad; it’s that advice, by default, rearranges the relationship into roles: one person as fixer, the other as fixable. Even when the content is sound, the posture can feel like a quiet downgrade.
As a sociologist, Lynd is alert to status, power, and the ways everyday interactions police belonging. Advice is never just information; it’s a social act that implies authority, judgment, and a standard the other person is failing to meet. Too much of it turns intimacy into a performance review. The friend dispensing wisdom gets to feel competent and generous. The friend receiving it is asked to be grateful, improved, and compliant - three states that don’t mix well with dignity.
The phrasing “will not stand the strain” makes friendship sound like a material with a stress limit. That’s the cynical elegance: affection can carry secrets, boredom, even conflict, but repeated “help” can be heavier than harm because it arrives dressed as virtue. Lynd’s context - an era obsessed with uplift, expertise, and proper living - sharpens the jab. He’s warning that friendship survives on recognition, not reform; if you want to keep someone close, resist the itch to turn them into a case.
As a sociologist, Lynd is alert to status, power, and the ways everyday interactions police belonging. Advice is never just information; it’s a social act that implies authority, judgment, and a standard the other person is failing to meet. Too much of it turns intimacy into a performance review. The friend dispensing wisdom gets to feel competent and generous. The friend receiving it is asked to be grateful, improved, and compliant - three states that don’t mix well with dignity.
The phrasing “will not stand the strain” makes friendship sound like a material with a stress limit. That’s the cynical elegance: affection can carry secrets, boredom, even conflict, but repeated “help” can be heavier than harm because it arrives dressed as virtue. Lynd’s context - an era obsessed with uplift, expertise, and proper living - sharpens the jab. He’s warning that friendship survives on recognition, not reform; if you want to keep someone close, resist the itch to turn them into a case.
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List









