"From the moment this war began, there was, for this state, only one policy possible, neutrality"
About this Quote
Neutrality here isn’t a mood; it’s a statecraft ultimatum dressed up as inevitability. De Valera’s line works because it pretends to remove choice from politics. “From the moment this war began” frames neutrality not as a debated stance but as an automatic reflex, as if Ireland’s sovereignty itself would short-circuit any other option. That rhetorical move is doing real labor: it converts a contested policy into a matter of national survival.
The phrase “for this state” is equally loaded. In the 1940s, the Irish state was still young, still defining itself against the long shadow of British rule and the unfinished business of partition. De Valera is speaking from the hard edge of legitimacy: if Ireland could be pulled into Britain’s war, then independence would look conditional, not real. Neutrality becomes a proof-of-life for sovereignty.
“Only one policy possible” also anticipates the moral heckling Ireland would receive, especially from the Allies, who could cast neutrality as cowardice or quiet sympathy. De Valera preempts that by arguing necessity, not preference. The subtext is blunt: Ireland lacks the military capacity to defend itself in a total war, and entry would invite catastrophe - German attack, British “protection,” or both. Neutrality is less a lofty principle than a shield against being used, occupied, or reabsorbed.
It’s the language of constrained agency: a small nation insisting that restraint can be an assertion, not an absence, of power.
The phrase “for this state” is equally loaded. In the 1940s, the Irish state was still young, still defining itself against the long shadow of British rule and the unfinished business of partition. De Valera is speaking from the hard edge of legitimacy: if Ireland could be pulled into Britain’s war, then independence would look conditional, not real. Neutrality becomes a proof-of-life for sovereignty.
“Only one policy possible” also anticipates the moral heckling Ireland would receive, especially from the Allies, who could cast neutrality as cowardice or quiet sympathy. De Valera preempts that by arguing necessity, not preference. The subtext is blunt: Ireland lacks the military capacity to defend itself in a total war, and entry would invite catastrophe - German attack, British “protection,” or both. Neutrality is less a lofty principle than a shield against being used, occupied, or reabsorbed.
It’s the language of constrained agency: a small nation insisting that restraint can be an assertion, not an absence, of power.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Eamon
Add to List
