"From their experience or from the recorded experience of others (history), men learn only what their passions and their metaphysical prejudices allow them to learn"
About this Quote
Huxley suggests that experience does not teach by itself; desire and doctrine do the editing. Passions decide what we notice, remember, and care to admit, while metaphysical prejudices our basic, often unexamined assumptions about reality and value determine what can count as a lesson at all. Two people can live through the same event or read the same history and extract opposite morals because they arrive with different hungers and frameworks. The raw data of life and of the past is abundant; the filter is within.
That filter includes fears and loyalties, the need to belong, status anxieties, moral sentiments, and grand narratives about human nature and destiny. These shape interpretations long before reason marshals its arguments. Confirmation bias and motivated reasoning dress themselves as objectivity, but they quietly serve prior commitments. Even science struggles with this, as research programs and paradigms reward certain questions and marginalize others. In politics, revolutionaries and reactionaries draw incompatible warnings from the same upheavals; every faction finds precedents that vindicate its ends. The lessons of history are plentiful mainly because people are skilled at finding the ones they want.
The line fits Huxleys broader worries about the 20th century. He saw how propaganda, mass entertainment, and ideology mobilized passions and hardened metaphysical certainties, making societies resistant to uncomfortable truths. Brave New World dramatizes not ignorance, but a managed appetite that prevents learning anything that might threaten stability. Later essays warned that technological sophistication without self-knowledge magnifies our prejudices rather than correcting them.
The implied remedy is not to abandon passion or metaphysics, but to make them conscious. Intellectual humility, habits of checking disconfirming evidence, exposure to rival worldviews, and a disciplined attention to the inconvenient can widen what we are able to learn. Without such inner work, experience becomes a mirror that reflects back only our desires and dogmas, and history turns into a quarry from which we extract stones to fortify the walls we already live behind.
That filter includes fears and loyalties, the need to belong, status anxieties, moral sentiments, and grand narratives about human nature and destiny. These shape interpretations long before reason marshals its arguments. Confirmation bias and motivated reasoning dress themselves as objectivity, but they quietly serve prior commitments. Even science struggles with this, as research programs and paradigms reward certain questions and marginalize others. In politics, revolutionaries and reactionaries draw incompatible warnings from the same upheavals; every faction finds precedents that vindicate its ends. The lessons of history are plentiful mainly because people are skilled at finding the ones they want.
The line fits Huxleys broader worries about the 20th century. He saw how propaganda, mass entertainment, and ideology mobilized passions and hardened metaphysical certainties, making societies resistant to uncomfortable truths. Brave New World dramatizes not ignorance, but a managed appetite that prevents learning anything that might threaten stability. Later essays warned that technological sophistication without self-knowledge magnifies our prejudices rather than correcting them.
The implied remedy is not to abandon passion or metaphysics, but to make them conscious. Intellectual humility, habits of checking disconfirming evidence, exposure to rival worldviews, and a disciplined attention to the inconvenient can widen what we are able to learn. Without such inner work, experience becomes a mirror that reflects back only our desires and dogmas, and history turns into a quarry from which we extract stones to fortify the walls we already live behind.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Aldous
Add to List
