"Generality is, indeed, an indispensable ingredient of reality; for mere individual existence or actuality without any regularity whatever is a nullity. Chaos is pure nothing"
About this Quote
Peirce is doing something sly here: he takes a word that sounds like a vice in ordinary speech - “generality,” the stuff of vague platitudes - and recasts it as reality’s secret backbone. The line is a rebuke to the fantasy that the world is just a pile of isolated facts, each one brute and self-contained. For Peirce, “mere individual existence” without “regularity” isn’t richly particular; it’s unintelligible. If nothing repeats, if nothing can be grouped, predicted, or recognized, then nothing can even count as a thing. “Chaos is pure nothing” lands like a metaphysical dunk: absolute disorder isn’t a darker, more intense reality, it’s the annihilation of meaning itself.
The intent sits inside Peirce’s broader pragmatist project and his realism about “generals” (laws, types, habits). He’s pushing back against nominalism, the view that only individual particulars are real while patterns are just names we slap on. His subtext is epistemological and ethical at once: knowledge requires public, shareable regularities, and so does community. A world made only of private, unrepeatable moments would be a world where inquiry can’t start, language can’t stabilize, and responsibility can’t attach.
The rhetoric works because it flips the usual hierarchy. We tend to treat laws as abstractions floating above the “real” gritty stuff. Peirce insists the opposite: the gritty stuff becomes real to us only insofar as it participates in a generality we can track. He’s not praising conformity; he’s defending the minimal structure that makes experience more than noise.
The intent sits inside Peirce’s broader pragmatist project and his realism about “generals” (laws, types, habits). He’s pushing back against nominalism, the view that only individual particulars are real while patterns are just names we slap on. His subtext is epistemological and ethical at once: knowledge requires public, shareable regularities, and so does community. A world made only of private, unrepeatable moments would be a world where inquiry can’t start, language can’t stabilize, and responsibility can’t attach.
The rhetoric works because it flips the usual hierarchy. We tend to treat laws as abstractions floating above the “real” gritty stuff. Peirce insists the opposite: the gritty stuff becomes real to us only insofar as it participates in a generality we can track. He’s not praising conformity; he’s defending the minimal structure that makes experience more than noise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
