"Giving is true having"
About this Quote
"Giving is true having" is Spurgeon at his most deceptively simple: a sentence that sounds like a gentle proverb but smuggles in a full theology of value. The pivot is the little word "true". He is not praising generosity as a nice add-on to wealth; he is redefining what counts as possession in the first place. In Spurgeon's moral economy, you don't "have" something because it sits in your account or on your shelf. You have it because it has been converted into love, relief, and communal life.
The subtext is an attack on the Victorian confidence that accumulation equals security. Industrial Britain produced spectacular fortunes alongside brutal poverty, and Spurgeon preached to both worlds. This line functions as a spiritual corrective to a culture learning to treat money as proof of merit. If wealth can be hoarded without consequence, then the rich can pretend their abundance is neutral. Spurgeon refuses that neutrality: unused goods are not "having" but a kind of moral dead weight.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it flips the instinctive meaning of ownership without sounding combative. It's aphoristic, memorable, almost arithmetic. Yet it carries a pastoral dare: if giving is the only real form of having, then selfishness is not merely unkind, it's impoverished. For a preacher known for vivid, street-level speech, the genius here is compression - a whole sermon reduced to a single reversible equation, where the soul's balance sheet only makes sense when the numbers leave your hands.
The subtext is an attack on the Victorian confidence that accumulation equals security. Industrial Britain produced spectacular fortunes alongside brutal poverty, and Spurgeon preached to both worlds. This line functions as a spiritual corrective to a culture learning to treat money as proof of merit. If wealth can be hoarded without consequence, then the rich can pretend their abundance is neutral. Spurgeon refuses that neutrality: unused goods are not "having" but a kind of moral dead weight.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it flips the instinctive meaning of ownership without sounding combative. It's aphoristic, memorable, almost arithmetic. Yet it carries a pastoral dare: if giving is the only real form of having, then selfishness is not merely unkind, it's impoverished. For a preacher known for vivid, street-level speech, the genius here is compression - a whole sermon reduced to a single reversible equation, where the soul's balance sheet only makes sense when the numbers leave your hands.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List








