"God expects from men something more than at such times, and that it were much to be wished for the credit of their religion as well as the satisfaction of their conscience that their Easter devotions would in some measure come up to their Easter dress"
About this Quote
South’s jab lands because it’s aimed at a familiar kind of piety: the decorative, seasonal version that asks little beyond looking the part. In the late 17th century, when the Church of England was rebuilding authority after civil war, regicide, Restoration, and fresh anxieties about dissent, “religion” wasn’t just private belief; it was social glue and public performance. Easter, with its crowded churches and heightened visibility, became a perfect stage for what South treats as spiritual cosplay.
The line works by yoking two kinds of “credit” together. There’s the credit of religion, meaning its reputation in the world, and the credit of the individual believer, meaning moral seriousness. South implies both are being quietly ruined by a mismatch: the polish of “Easter dress” outstripping the discipline of “Easter devotions.” The syntax is deliberately overloaded, almost judicial, as if he’s issuing a verdict rather than offering advice. That weight is part of the threat: you may be able to impress your neighbors, but your conscience won’t be fooled.
The subtext is less about fashion than about hypocrisy as a civic problem. If Christianity is reduced to pageantry, it becomes easy to dismiss, easy to weaponize, and easy to abandon when inconvenient. South’s most pointed move is tactical: he doesn’t condemn celebration itself; he condemns the asymmetry. Dress is fine, he suggests, as long as devotion can keep up. That small concession makes the rebuke sharper, not softer.
The line works by yoking two kinds of “credit” together. There’s the credit of religion, meaning its reputation in the world, and the credit of the individual believer, meaning moral seriousness. South implies both are being quietly ruined by a mismatch: the polish of “Easter dress” outstripping the discipline of “Easter devotions.” The syntax is deliberately overloaded, almost judicial, as if he’s issuing a verdict rather than offering advice. That weight is part of the threat: you may be able to impress your neighbors, but your conscience won’t be fooled.
The subtext is less about fashion than about hypocrisy as a civic problem. If Christianity is reduced to pageantry, it becomes easy to dismiss, easy to weaponize, and easy to abandon when inconvenient. South’s most pointed move is tactical: he doesn’t condemn celebration itself; he condemns the asymmetry. Dress is fine, he suggests, as long as devotion can keep up. That small concession makes the rebuke sharper, not softer.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
