"Good advice is always certain to be ignored, but that's no reason not to give it"
About this Quote
Advice, in Christie’s hands, isn’t a noble gift so much as a tiny social experiment with a predictable result. The line has the tidy snap of a detective’s summary: premise, evidence, verdict. People ignore good advice. Case closed. What gives it bite is the second clause, which refuses the sentimental payoff. She doesn’t pretend wisdom is persuasive; she insists it’s still an obligation.
The intent feels double-edged. On one level, it’s permission to stop taking rejection personally. If the best counsel is “certain to be ignored,” then the failure isn’t yours; it’s baked into human nature, that stubborn confidence that we’re the exception to patterns we can plainly see. Christie spent a career watching characters walk toward the obvious trap because desire, pride, and narrative momentum are stronger than caution. The reader knows. The detective knows. The suspect still does it.
The subtext is darker and more practical: giving advice isn’t about controlling outcomes; it’s about drawing a moral boundary. You warn someone not because you believe they’ll listen, but because not warning makes you complicit. It’s also a quiet critique of the “I told you so” impulse. If ignoring advice is inevitable, then the advisor’s job isn’t to gloat later; it’s to speak clearly now.
Context matters: Christie wrote through wars, social upheaval, and the steady collapse of Victorian certainty. Her mysteries are full of missed signals and ignored warnings. The line reads like a writer’s credo for living among fallible people: keep offering clarity, even when the plot demands they won’t take it.
The intent feels double-edged. On one level, it’s permission to stop taking rejection personally. If the best counsel is “certain to be ignored,” then the failure isn’t yours; it’s baked into human nature, that stubborn confidence that we’re the exception to patterns we can plainly see. Christie spent a career watching characters walk toward the obvious trap because desire, pride, and narrative momentum are stronger than caution. The reader knows. The detective knows. The suspect still does it.
The subtext is darker and more practical: giving advice isn’t about controlling outcomes; it’s about drawing a moral boundary. You warn someone not because you believe they’ll listen, but because not warning makes you complicit. It’s also a quiet critique of the “I told you so” impulse. If ignoring advice is inevitable, then the advisor’s job isn’t to gloat later; it’s to speak clearly now.
Context matters: Christie wrote through wars, social upheaval, and the steady collapse of Victorian certainty. Her mysteries are full of missed signals and ignored warnings. The line reads like a writer’s credo for living among fallible people: keep offering clarity, even when the plot demands they won’t take it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Agatha
Add to List







