"Government is an evil; it is only the thoughtlessness and vices of men that make it a necessary evil. When all men are good and wise, government will of itself decay"
About this Quote
Shelley doesn’t just distrust government; he treats it as a symptom, like smoke from a fire most people refuse to see. Calling government “an evil” is meant to jar, but the real target is in the next clause: “thoughtlessness and vices.” Power isn’t the original sin here; moral and intellectual laziness is. The line flatters and indicts at once: if you hate being ruled, stop being the kind of person who makes rulers plausible.
It’s classic Romantic politics in miniature, where the imagination isn’t escape but infrastructure. Shelley’s utopia isn’t built by better constitutions; it’s built by better humans. That’s why the mechanism is so elegantly radical: when “all men are good and wise,” government won’t be abolished by revolution so much as made obsolete, “decay” arriving like an unused organ. The word choice matters. “Decay” implies something unnatural about government’s persistence, a parasitic growth sustained by human failing, not a neutral tool we can simply recalibrate.
Context sharpens the provocation. Shelley writes in the long afterglow of the French Revolution, when hopes for liberation had curdled into terror, empire, and reactionary crackdowns in Britain. His refusal to romanticize the state reads as a rebuke to both conservatives who sacralize authority and reformers who think swapping regimes solves the deeper problem. Subtext: political change without moral awakening is just redecorating the prison.
It’s classic Romantic politics in miniature, where the imagination isn’t escape but infrastructure. Shelley’s utopia isn’t built by better constitutions; it’s built by better humans. That’s why the mechanism is so elegantly radical: when “all men are good and wise,” government won’t be abolished by revolution so much as made obsolete, “decay” arriving like an unused organ. The word choice matters. “Decay” implies something unnatural about government’s persistence, a parasitic growth sustained by human failing, not a neutral tool we can simply recalibrate.
Context sharpens the provocation. Shelley writes in the long afterglow of the French Revolution, when hopes for liberation had curdled into terror, empire, and reactionary crackdowns in Britain. His refusal to romanticize the state reads as a rebuke to both conservatives who sacralize authority and reformers who think swapping regimes solves the deeper problem. Subtext: political change without moral awakening is just redecorating the prison.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Percy
Add to List










