"Greek was very much a live language, and a language still unconscious of grammar, not, like ours, dominated by definitions and trained upon dictionaries"
About this Quote
Greek, in Murray's telling, isn't a museum piece but a creature still breathing on its own. The bite comes from the phrase "unconscious of grammar": not ignorant, but unselfconscious. He frames classical Greek as a language that hasn't yet been corralled by rulebooks, a medium where meaning is negotiated in the moment rather than policed by reference works. It's a romantic image, but it's also a critique aimed squarely at modern linguistic habits: our tendency to treat dictionaries as courts and definitions as verdicts.
The subtext is about power. "Dominated" and "trained" are the verbs of discipline, suggesting a modern culture that mistrusts improvisation and prefers standardization, credentialing, and textual authority. Murray is praising Greek not only for its expressiveness, but for the social world it implies: speakers oriented toward rhetoric, debate, and public life, less toward bureaucratic correctness. That idealization fits a certain early-20th-century classicist mood, where antiquity becomes a mirror for anxieties about mechanization, mass education, and administrative modernity.
Context matters: Murray was a celebrated Hellenist as well as a diplomat, and diplomacy lives or dies on nuance, ambiguity, and the strategic use of language. His admiration for a "live language" doubles as a professional yearning for speech that can move quickly, persuade, and adapt, unhampered by the anxious micromanagement of words. It's not just nostalgia; it's a warning about what gets lost when language becomes a compliance system.
The subtext is about power. "Dominated" and "trained" are the verbs of discipline, suggesting a modern culture that mistrusts improvisation and prefers standardization, credentialing, and textual authority. Murray is praising Greek not only for its expressiveness, but for the social world it implies: speakers oriented toward rhetoric, debate, and public life, less toward bureaucratic correctness. That idealization fits a certain early-20th-century classicist mood, where antiquity becomes a mirror for anxieties about mechanization, mass education, and administrative modernity.
Context matters: Murray was a celebrated Hellenist as well as a diplomat, and diplomacy lives or dies on nuance, ambiguity, and the strategic use of language. His admiration for a "live language" doubles as a professional yearning for speech that can move quickly, persuade, and adapt, unhampered by the anxious micromanagement of words. It's not just nostalgia; it's a warning about what gets lost when language becomes a compliance system.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by Gilbert
Add to List


