"Habit is a second nature which prevents us from knowing the first, of which it has neither the cruelties nor the enchantments"
About this Quote
Proust treats habit less like a cozy routine and more like a velvet curtain drawn across reality. The sentence is built on a sly reversal: we call habit "second nature" to praise how seamlessly it fits us, but Proust uses that very seamlessness as an indictment. Habit doesn’t just help us live; it edits what we’re able to notice. It becomes an anesthetic that dulls sensation, turning the world from an event into a backdrop.
The line’s bite comes from its double comparison. First nature, for Proust, is messy and electrically alive: it contains "cruelties" (the shocks of desire, jealousy, grief, boredom) and "enchantments" (the sudden, almost violent pleasures of perception). Habit lacks both. It doesn’t wound, but it also can’t intoxicate. That’s the quiet tragedy: comfort as a form of impoverishment. By preventing us from "knowing the first", habit doesn’t merely obscure; it replaces, installing a more manageable life that is also less legible, less intense.
Context matters. In Proust’s world, the project of art is the recovery of lost experience - the way a taste, a sound, a texture can crack open time and restore the self to itself. Habit is the antagonist of that project, the mechanism by which life becomes unremembered even while it’s being lived. The subtext is almost moral: to perceive deeply is to risk pain, but to surrender to habit is to forfeit the very enchantment that makes pain worth surviving.
The line’s bite comes from its double comparison. First nature, for Proust, is messy and electrically alive: it contains "cruelties" (the shocks of desire, jealousy, grief, boredom) and "enchantments" (the sudden, almost violent pleasures of perception). Habit lacks both. It doesn’t wound, but it also can’t intoxicate. That’s the quiet tragedy: comfort as a form of impoverishment. By preventing us from "knowing the first", habit doesn’t merely obscure; it replaces, installing a more manageable life that is also less legible, less intense.
Context matters. In Proust’s world, the project of art is the recovery of lost experience - the way a taste, a sound, a texture can crack open time and restore the self to itself. Habit is the antagonist of that project, the mechanism by which life becomes unremembered even while it’s being lived. The subtext is almost moral: to perceive deeply is to risk pain, but to surrender to habit is to forfeit the very enchantment that makes pain worth surviving.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Marcel
Add to List
