Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Nicolas Malebranche

"He has willed - He wills incessantly - that the modifications of the mind and those of the body shall be reciprocal. This is the conjunction and the natural dependence of the two parts of which we are constituted"

About this Quote

Malebranche’s God is not a distant clockmaker; he’s a relentless systems administrator. “He has willed - He wills incessantly” is the tell: the hyphenated insistence turns divine action into a continuous process, not a one-time setup. In late-17th-century France, with Cartesian dualism splitting mind and body into radically different substances, that verb choice matters. Malebranche is trying to keep Descartes’s split while solving the scandal it creates: if mind and body are different kinds of thing, how do they interact without smuggling in magic?

His answer is “reciprocal” modification by decree. The subtext is both pious and polemical. Pious, because it routes causal power away from human faculties and into God’s ongoing will; your intention doesn’t move your arm because “mind” has muscle-like force, but because God has established (and continually maintains) a dependable correspondence between volitions and bodily motions. Polemical, because it undercuts the emerging temptation to treat the mind-body relation as a purely mechanical interface that science alone can explain.

The phrase “conjunction and the natural dependence” is the rhetorical sleight of hand. “Natural” sounds like physiology, but it’s really theology in a lab coat: the dependence feels natural precisely because it’s regular, not because it’s self-sufficient. Malebranche is selling comfort through predictability. You can trust your perceptions and actions because the universe is run by a will that doesn’t take days off, even if that trust comes at the cost of genuine creaturely causation.

Quote Details

TopicReason & Logic
More Quotes by Nicolas Add to List
Malebranche on Mind-Body Conjunction and Divine Will
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

France Flag

Nicolas Malebranche (August 6, 1638 - October 13, 1715) was a Philosopher from France.

16 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Leon Battista Alberti, Architect
Benjamin Franklin, Politician
Benjamin Franklin