"He said this has the potential to be the first broadband killer application, and it has sort of become the truth because obviously it's so bandwidth intensive. I mean, it has been an issue"
About this Quote
A pioneer of digital disruption trying, politely, not to sound like he’s gloating. Fanning’s line is steeped in the late-’90s/early-2000s tension where the internet’s promise was sold as empowerment and connection, but its breakout use case was people moving enormous files around in ways the gatekeepers didn’t authorize. Calling it the “first broadband killer application” frames bandwidth not as infrastructure but as destiny: broadband won’t win because telecoms or policymakers made a good case, it’ll win because users found something irresistible to do with it.
The phrasing is tellingly hedged: “has the potential,” “sort of become the truth,” “obviously.” It’s the language of someone who knows the argument is already settled in practice. The subtext is that culture, not commerce, forces technology forward. People didn’t crave faster connections in the abstract; they craved frictionless access to music (and later video), and speed became the tax you pay to keep up with desire.
There’s also a quiet reframing of blame. “It has been an issue” makes the consequences sound like a neutral engineering hiccup rather than a social rupture: networks strained, incumbents panicked, lawsuits proliferated, and “bandwidth intensive” became a euphemism for mass participation in a gray-market commons. Fanning’s understated cadence captures the era’s weird innocence: everyone could see the future arriving, but no one wanted to fully own what they’d unleashed.
The phrasing is tellingly hedged: “has the potential,” “sort of become the truth,” “obviously.” It’s the language of someone who knows the argument is already settled in practice. The subtext is that culture, not commerce, forces technology forward. People didn’t crave faster connections in the abstract; they craved frictionless access to music (and later video), and speed became the tax you pay to keep up with desire.
There’s also a quiet reframing of blame. “It has been an issue” makes the consequences sound like a neutral engineering hiccup rather than a social rupture: networks strained, incumbents panicked, lawsuits proliferated, and “bandwidth intensive” became a euphemism for mass participation in a gray-market commons. Fanning’s understated cadence captures the era’s weird innocence: everyone could see the future arriving, but no one wanted to fully own what they’d unleashed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Internet |
|---|
More Quotes by Shawn
Add to List

