"He steps on stage and draws the sword of rhetoric, and when he is through, someone is lying wounded and thousands of others are either angry or consoled"
About this Quote
Public speech, Hamill implies, is never a tea service. It is a blade, and the speaker who "draws the sword of rhetoric" isn’t merely performing; he’s entering combat on behalf of a story about reality that will leave casualties. The line works because it refuses the comforting myth that words are weightless. Rhetoric lands in bodies: reputations get punctured, enemies get made, scapegoats get crowned. Even the crowd’s reactions are sorted into two primal outcomes - "angry or consoled" - as if persuasion is less about enlightenment than emotional triage.
Hamill’s journalist’s eye sharpens the metaphor. He’s spent decades watching politicians, preachers, union leaders, and demagogues turn a microphone into a weapon. The "someone is lying wounded" isn’t necessarily the opponent onstage; it can be the truth, nicked by a clever line, or the public, nicked by a lie that feels good. The fact that it’s "someone" singular against "thousands" plural hints at the asymmetry of mass rhetoric: one person pays the price, many people get the mood they came for.
There’s also a warning tucked into the applause. If thousands leave "consoled", it may be because they were told what they already wanted to believe. Hamill isn’t condemning eloquence; he’s describing its moral risk. A great speech doesn’t just move a room. It chooses a target, draws blood, and calls that impact persuasion.
Hamill’s journalist’s eye sharpens the metaphor. He’s spent decades watching politicians, preachers, union leaders, and demagogues turn a microphone into a weapon. The "someone is lying wounded" isn’t necessarily the opponent onstage; it can be the truth, nicked by a clever line, or the public, nicked by a lie that feels good. The fact that it’s "someone" singular against "thousands" plural hints at the asymmetry of mass rhetoric: one person pays the price, many people get the mood they came for.
There’s also a warning tucked into the applause. If thousands leave "consoled", it may be because they were told what they already wanted to believe. Hamill isn’t condemning eloquence; he’s describing its moral risk. A great speech doesn’t just move a room. It chooses a target, draws blood, and calls that impact persuasion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Pete
Add to List









