"He wanted to play accordion on something of mine and I said you can play accordion, but I want you to play piano and organ on some stuff. He came over a couple times a week for two weeks and gave me therapy as to whether I should do The Thorns or not"
About this Quote
The funniest thing about this little studio anecdote is how casually Matthew Sweet demotes the myth of the solitary genius. A collaborator shows up offering an accordion - the kind of charming left-field texture that screams “guest spot” - and Sweet counters with a practical trade: sure, bring the novelty, but also give me the foundation. Piano and organ aren’t just colors; they’re scaffolding. The negotiation is musical, but it’s also about control: Sweet is open to other voices as long as they serve the architecture of his songs.
Then he drops the real reveal: the sessions doubled as “therapy” about whether he should do The Thorns. That word is doing a lot of work. It implies he wasn’t only weighing chord changes or scheduling, but identity. Joining a band, especially a “supergroup”-adjacent project like The Thorns, can feel like a referendum on your own narrative: Are you expanding, or admitting you can’t carry it alone? Are you collaborating, or diluting the brand?
The rhythm of “a couple times a week for two weeks” grounds the drama in ordinary life - decisions get made not in lightning-bolt epiphanies but in repeated conversations between takes. Sweet frames musicianship as a kind of emotional labor exchange: you come in to play, you also come in to listen. In that sense, the quote captures a whole era of alt-pop adulthood, where the hard part isn’t making music; it’s deciding what kind of life the music will require.
Then he drops the real reveal: the sessions doubled as “therapy” about whether he should do The Thorns. That word is doing a lot of work. It implies he wasn’t only weighing chord changes or scheduling, but identity. Joining a band, especially a “supergroup”-adjacent project like The Thorns, can feel like a referendum on your own narrative: Are you expanding, or admitting you can’t carry it alone? Are you collaborating, or diluting the brand?
The rhythm of “a couple times a week for two weeks” grounds the drama in ordinary life - decisions get made not in lightning-bolt epiphanies but in repeated conversations between takes. Sweet frames musicianship as a kind of emotional labor exchange: you come in to play, you also come in to listen. In that sense, the quote captures a whole era of alt-pop adulthood, where the hard part isn’t making music; it’s deciding what kind of life the music will require.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Matthew
Add to List





