"He was definitely known as the foremost man killer in the West; however there's controversy about virtually every killing that he was known to have been involved in"
About this Quote
Carradine’s line plays like a wink at the whole Western mythmaking machine: crown someone “the foremost man killer in the West,” then immediately pull the rug out from under the legend. The sentence carries two competing American appetites in the same breath - for clean, swaggering folklore and for the anxious modern need to fact-check the folklore to death.
The intent isn’t to solve the historical record; it’s to dramatize how reputations are manufactured. “Definitely known” is a sneaky phrase: it signals certainty, but only about the existence of a story, not about whether the story is true. That’s the subtextual pivot. Fame becomes a kind of hearsay that hardens into “history,” especially in a genre where violence doubles as currency. The “however” is doing heavy lifting, shifting the focus from the alleged killings to the culture that can’t stop retelling them.
Contextually, it lands in a late-20th-century, post-revisionist Western mood, where filmmakers and audiences are more suspicious of heroic bloodshed. Carradine, as an actor, speaks from inside a business that turns murky lives into marketable archetypes. The controversy “about virtually every killing” suggests that what’s durable isn’t the truth but the narrative silhouette: a name, a tally, a persona. It’s an indictment delivered casually, almost offhand - which is exactly why it works. The line treats lethal legend as a PR problem, and in doing so exposes how thin the line is between an outlaw’s biography and a studio’s branding strategy.
The intent isn’t to solve the historical record; it’s to dramatize how reputations are manufactured. “Definitely known” is a sneaky phrase: it signals certainty, but only about the existence of a story, not about whether the story is true. That’s the subtextual pivot. Fame becomes a kind of hearsay that hardens into “history,” especially in a genre where violence doubles as currency. The “however” is doing heavy lifting, shifting the focus from the alleged killings to the culture that can’t stop retelling them.
Contextually, it lands in a late-20th-century, post-revisionist Western mood, where filmmakers and audiences are more suspicious of heroic bloodshed. Carradine, as an actor, speaks from inside a business that turns murky lives into marketable archetypes. The controversy “about virtually every killing” suggests that what’s durable isn’t the truth but the narrative silhouette: a name, a tally, a persona. It’s an indictment delivered casually, almost offhand - which is exactly why it works. The line treats lethal legend as a PR problem, and in doing so exposes how thin the line is between an outlaw’s biography and a studio’s branding strategy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Keith
Add to List

