"He was very much concerned with logic and function, he always worked his solos out before playing them"
About this Quote
It lands like a quiet correction to the rock myth that greatness is born in the moment. Jamie Muir’s line frames “logic and function” as the hidden engine behind a supposedly wild art form: the guitar solo as architecture, not accident. In a culture that loves to romanticize improvisation as pure feeling, Muir points to something less glamorous and more revealing - premeditation.
The specific intent is partly admiration, partly demystification. “Very much concerned” and “always” aren’t casual qualifiers; they insist on a pattern. Whoever “he” is, the solos weren’t lucky lightning strikes but designed statements, worked out in advance until they did what they needed to do. That’s the “function” piece: a solo isn’t just a flex, it’s a narrative tool that has to land emotionally, harmonically, and structurally inside a song.
The subtext is also a little jab at a certain strain of rock authenticity. Muir suggests that discipline doesn’t make the music colder; it makes it reliable, repeatable, communicative. Planning becomes a kind of respect - for the audience, for the band, for the composition. It’s also a reminder that “spontaneity” onstage is often a performance of spontaneity, the product of hours of private labor.
Contextually, coming from a musician, it reads like inside-baseball truth-telling: virtuosity isn’t just chops, it’s decisions. The line rehabilitates craft as a radical value in a genre that often pretends craft is cheating.
The specific intent is partly admiration, partly demystification. “Very much concerned” and “always” aren’t casual qualifiers; they insist on a pattern. Whoever “he” is, the solos weren’t lucky lightning strikes but designed statements, worked out in advance until they did what they needed to do. That’s the “function” piece: a solo isn’t just a flex, it’s a narrative tool that has to land emotionally, harmonically, and structurally inside a song.
The subtext is also a little jab at a certain strain of rock authenticity. Muir suggests that discipline doesn’t make the music colder; it makes it reliable, repeatable, communicative. Planning becomes a kind of respect - for the audience, for the band, for the composition. It’s also a reminder that “spontaneity” onstage is often a performance of spontaneity, the product of hours of private labor.
Contextually, coming from a musician, it reads like inside-baseball truth-telling: virtuosity isn’t just chops, it’s decisions. The line rehabilitates craft as a radical value in a genre that often pretends craft is cheating.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Jamie
Add to List
