"He who does not know how to create should not know"
About this Quote
Porchia turns ignorance into a moral stance: if you can’t make, you shouldn’t even claim the comfort of knowing. The line lands like a paradox but reads like a warning shot at the kind of knowledge that never risks itself in the world. “Create” here isn’t just art-making; it’s any act that transforms raw material into something with consequences. Knowing without creating becomes a form of consumption, a spectator sport. Porchia suggests that the right to “know” is earned through the discipline of shaping, failing, revising - the lived friction that theory alone can’t provide.
The sentence’s sting comes from its clipped absolutism. He doesn’t say “may not” or “should consider.” He says “should not know,” collapsing epistemology into ethics. The subtext is anti-credential, anti-posture: beware the expert who can name every move but never steps onto the field. It’s also a jab at the safety of commentary, where judgment is cheap because nothing is at stake. Creation, by contrast, is exposure.
Context matters: Porchia’s Voices is built from aphorisms that behave like spiritual koans and streetwise proverbs at once, written by an Italian immigrant in Argentina who lived outside literary institutions. That outsider vantage hardens into a suspicion of secondhand certainty. In a culture saturated with takes, Porchia’s line reads less like mystical minimalism and more like a demand: if you want to know, put your hands on the material. Let knowledge bear the scars of making.
The sentence’s sting comes from its clipped absolutism. He doesn’t say “may not” or “should consider.” He says “should not know,” collapsing epistemology into ethics. The subtext is anti-credential, anti-posture: beware the expert who can name every move but never steps onto the field. It’s also a jab at the safety of commentary, where judgment is cheap because nothing is at stake. Creation, by contrast, is exposure.
Context matters: Porchia’s Voices is built from aphorisms that behave like spiritual koans and streetwise proverbs at once, written by an Italian immigrant in Argentina who lived outside literary institutions. That outsider vantage hardens into a suspicion of secondhand certainty. In a culture saturated with takes, Porchia’s line reads less like mystical minimalism and more like a demand: if you want to know, put your hands on the material. Let knowledge bear the scars of making.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Antonio
Add to List









