"He who has not Christmas in his heart will never find it under a tree"
About this Quote
Christmas isn’t hiding under the tree; it’s hiding in you. Roy L. Smith, a clergyman, frames the holiday as an inward condition rather than an outward event, and the line works because it punctures the consumer-script without sounding like a scold. The image is domestic and almost childlike - a tree, a search, the hopeful crouch of someone looking for magic in wrapping paper. Then Smith flips it: if you don’t bring the meaning with you, the props won’t supply it.
The intent is pastoral and preventative. He’s talking to people who want the feeling - warmth, wonder, reconciliation - but try to purchase it through ritual, decor, or generosity performed like a receipt. The subtext is moral psychology: you can’t outsource joy or spiritual belonging to objects. Even family traditions, in this view, are only amplifiers; they can’t generate what isn’t already there.
Context matters: as a preacher in an era when Christmas was becoming increasingly commercial (and increasingly sentimental), Smith is reclaiming the holiday from its stagecraft. “Heart” carries theological weight - not just emotion, but orientation, the inner seat of intention. The line also quietly warns against cynicism: if you show up armored with resentment, loneliness, or performative detachment, the season will faithfully reflect that back. The tree becomes a test. Not of how much you have, but of what you’re willing to practice: attention, gratitude, mercy, awe.
The intent is pastoral and preventative. He’s talking to people who want the feeling - warmth, wonder, reconciliation - but try to purchase it through ritual, decor, or generosity performed like a receipt. The subtext is moral psychology: you can’t outsource joy or spiritual belonging to objects. Even family traditions, in this view, are only amplifiers; they can’t generate what isn’t already there.
Context matters: as a preacher in an era when Christmas was becoming increasingly commercial (and increasingly sentimental), Smith is reclaiming the holiday from its stagecraft. “Heart” carries theological weight - not just emotion, but orientation, the inner seat of intention. The line also quietly warns against cynicism: if you show up armored with resentment, loneliness, or performative detachment, the season will faithfully reflect that back. The tree becomes a test. Not of how much you have, but of what you’re willing to practice: attention, gratitude, mercy, awe.
Quote Details
| Topic | Christmas |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: The Christmas Field (Barb Bissonette, 2023) modern compilationISBN: 9781682358108 · ID: 2D_SEAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... He who has not Christmas in his heart will never find it under a tree.” —Roy L. Smith. Chapter. 6. hat Christmas stood out in my mind because it was the. T. first, and yes, only time that my mother came out to The Christmas Field. Uncle Ken ... Other candidates (1) Dogs (Roy L. Smith) compilation40.0% he toils not neither does he spin yet solomon in all his glory never lay upon a doorma |
| Featured | This quote was our Quote of the Day on December 24, 2025 |
More Quotes by Roy
Add to List












