"Hear the other side"
About this Quote
A command that sounds like basic fairness becomes, in Augustine’s hands, a spiritual discipline: listen, or you’ll mistake your own certainty for truth. “Hear the other side” isn’t the breezy liberal ideal of giving everyone a turn; it’s a warning about the ego’s talent for self-justification. Augustine knew that the mind can build a perfectly coherent case for the wrong life. His own biography is basically a conversion narrative powered by competing voices: Manichaeans, skeptics, Platonists, bishops, his mother Monica, and finally the unsettling interior voice of Scripture. The line carries that lived experience of being argued out of yourself.
The intent is also pastoral and judicial. Late Roman North Africa was a courtroom culture, and Augustine wrote constantly against rival Christian movements (Donatists), pagans, and heretics. “The other side” includes actual opponents, but it also includes the parts of the self we’d rather not consult: conscience, confession, the poor, the suffering neighbor. Subtext: your first story about events is not trustworthy, especially when it flatters you. Humility is epistemology.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it’s bare and imperative. No theology jargon, no elaborate syllogism. It’s a wedge driven into the moment where we want closure. Augustine’s Christianity is often caricatured as authoritarian certainty, yet here he’s insisting that truth requires exposure to contradiction. Not because every side is equal, but because without the other side, you never discover where your arguments are just disguises for desire.
The intent is also pastoral and judicial. Late Roman North Africa was a courtroom culture, and Augustine wrote constantly against rival Christian movements (Donatists), pagans, and heretics. “The other side” includes actual opponents, but it also includes the parts of the self we’d rather not consult: conscience, confession, the poor, the suffering neighbor. Subtext: your first story about events is not trustworthy, especially when it flatters you. Humility is epistemology.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it’s bare and imperative. No theology jargon, no elaborate syllogism. It’s a wedge driven into the moment where we want closure. Augustine’s Christianity is often caricatured as authoritarian certainty, yet here he’s insisting that truth requires exposure to contradiction. Not because every side is equal, but because without the other side, you never discover where your arguments are just disguises for desire.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Saint
Add to List






