"Here, class attendance is expected and students are required to take notes, which they are tested on. What is missing, it seems to me, is the use of knowledge, the practical training"
About this Quote
The complaint lands like a polite indictment: an education system that treats learning as a compliance ritual. Salisbury’s phrasing is tellingly bureaucratic - “attendance is expected,” “required to take notes,” “tested on” - a chain of passive obligations that turns students into record-keepers and teachers into proctors. He’s not just critiquing pedagogy; he’s spotting a culture that confuses discipline with competence.
As a journalist, Salisbury is trained to look past official claims to the lived reality underneath. The subtext is that the institution can produce impressive transcripts and still fail at the only outcome that matters: usable judgment. “Notes” become a symbol of secondhand knowledge, information preserved rather than metabolized. Testing, in this frame, measures fidelity to the lecture, not the ability to deploy ideas under pressure. The line “What is missing, it seems to me” carries the restraint of a foreign correspondent: he’s reporting, not ranting, while letting the reader feel the absurdity.
Contextually, Salisbury wrote in a century obsessed with systems - industrial production, bureaucratic governance, ideological schooling. His wording suggests he’s observing an environment where standardization is prized because it’s legible to authority. Practical training is threatening: it produces agency, improvisation, and the possibility of dissent. By ending on “the use of knowledge,” he pushes education out of the classroom and into the mess of reality, where answers aren’t multiple-choice and competence can’t be faked by neat handwriting.
As a journalist, Salisbury is trained to look past official claims to the lived reality underneath. The subtext is that the institution can produce impressive transcripts and still fail at the only outcome that matters: usable judgment. “Notes” become a symbol of secondhand knowledge, information preserved rather than metabolized. Testing, in this frame, measures fidelity to the lecture, not the ability to deploy ideas under pressure. The line “What is missing, it seems to me” carries the restraint of a foreign correspondent: he’s reporting, not ranting, while letting the reader feel the absurdity.
Contextually, Salisbury wrote in a century obsessed with systems - industrial production, bureaucratic governance, ideological schooling. His wording suggests he’s observing an environment where standardization is prized because it’s legible to authority. Practical training is threatening: it produces agency, improvisation, and the possibility of dissent. By ending on “the use of knowledge,” he pushes education out of the classroom and into the mess of reality, where answers aren’t multiple-choice and competence can’t be faked by neat handwriting.
Quote Details
| Topic | Teaching |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Harrison
Add to List




