"Here I am paying big money to you writers and what for? All you do is change the words"
About this Quote
Hollywood has always loved writers the way it loves plumbing: essential, expensive, and only noticed when something leaks. Samuel Goldwyn's jab lands because it weaponizes a producer's most private irritation into a public punchline: the uncomfortable truth that writing is both the engine of a movie and the easiest craft for outsiders to casually dismiss. "Paying big money" isn't just a complaint about budgets; it's a flex. Goldwyn positions himself as the realist with the checkbook, staring at an invisible product. If the work is "just changing the words", then the labor can be priced down, hurried up, or second-guessed into oblivion.
The joke also reveals a power arrangement. Producers buy certainty; writers sell possibility. A screenplay lives in drafts, and drafts look like indecision to people who crave a fixed object they can approve. Goldwyn, a famously malaprop-prone mogul, is also slyly defending the producer's auteur myth: the film exists because he willed it into being, while the writer merely fusses with phrasing. It's funny because it's wrong in an almost correct way: movies really are made of words until they're made of images, and that translation is where fortunes are won or wasted.
Culturally, it captures the industry's chronic ambivalence about authorship. Writers are hired for their voice, then punished for using it. Goldwyn's line survives because it compresses that contradiction into a single, quotable act of condescension.
The joke also reveals a power arrangement. Producers buy certainty; writers sell possibility. A screenplay lives in drafts, and drafts look like indecision to people who crave a fixed object they can approve. Goldwyn, a famously malaprop-prone mogul, is also slyly defending the producer's auteur myth: the film exists because he willed it into being, while the writer merely fusses with phrasing. It's funny because it's wrong in an almost correct way: movies really are made of words until they're made of images, and that translation is where fortunes are won or wasted.
Culturally, it captures the industry's chronic ambivalence about authorship. Writers are hired for their voice, then punished for using it. Goldwyn's line survives because it compresses that contradiction into a single, quotable act of condescension.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List



