"Here's the simplest answer: Within weeks, the disciples proclaimed the resurrection of Jesus Christ, that He had been bodily raised from the dead and appeared to them"
About this Quote
McDowell opens with a sales pitch masquerading as modesty: "Here's the simplest answer". That phrase isn’t just about clarity; it’s a rhetorical power move. By promising simplicity, he sidesteps the expectation of scholarly caveats and plants the idea that any complicated alternative is evasive, overthought, maybe even ideologically motivated. The line is engineered for an audience that suspects academics of making obvious truths unnecessarily murky.
The real payload sits in "Within weeks". It’s a timeline compressed into an argument: if the disciples preached the resurrection almost immediately, the thinking goes, they couldn’t have fabricated a legend, misremembered, or gradually mythologized their grief into theology. It’s not proof so much as pressure. McDowell is using speed as a proxy for authenticity, turning chronology into credibility.
Then comes the insistence on "bodily raised" and "appeared to them". This is boundary-setting inside Christian debate as much as it is persuasion aimed outward. "Bodily" rejects symbolic or spiritualized readings; "appeared" stakes the claim on eyewitness-style testimony rather than private revelation. The subtext is courtroom: testimony, proximity, and a fact pattern that can be cross-examined.
Culturally, it fits late-20th-century evangelical apologetics: faith translated into argument, sermon reframed as evidence. McDowell’s intent isn’t to narrate Easter; it’s to make belief feel like the most reasonable conclusion for a modern, skepticism-trained listener who still wants certainty.
The real payload sits in "Within weeks". It’s a timeline compressed into an argument: if the disciples preached the resurrection almost immediately, the thinking goes, they couldn’t have fabricated a legend, misremembered, or gradually mythologized their grief into theology. It’s not proof so much as pressure. McDowell is using speed as a proxy for authenticity, turning chronology into credibility.
Then comes the insistence on "bodily raised" and "appeared to them". This is boundary-setting inside Christian debate as much as it is persuasion aimed outward. "Bodily" rejects symbolic or spiritualized readings; "appeared" stakes the claim on eyewitness-style testimony rather than private revelation. The subtext is courtroom: testimony, proximity, and a fact pattern that can be cross-examined.
Culturally, it fits late-20th-century evangelical apologetics: faith translated into argument, sermon reframed as evidence. McDowell’s intent isn’t to narrate Easter; it’s to make belief feel like the most reasonable conclusion for a modern, skepticism-trained listener who still wants certainty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Josh
Add to List


