"Hezbollah's contempt for human suffering is total, as it showed once again this morning when its rockets murdered two Israeli Arab children in Nazareth"
About this Quote
“Contempt for human suffering is total” is the kind of absolutist moral language diplomats usually ration. Tom Lantos deploys it anyway, because the sentence isn’t aimed at persuading Hezbollah; it’s aimed at collapsing any residual ambiguity for an American and international audience. “Total” forecloses the familiar hedges of asymmetrical warfare - misfires, tragic errors, proportionality debates - and recasts the event as evidence of an essence: cruelty not as incident, but as identity.
The most pointed move comes next: “two Israeli Arab children in Nazareth.” This is not incidental detail, it’s a strategic rebuttal. By foregrounding Arab victims inside Israel, Lantos punctures a common justificatory story in which Hezbollah’s violence is framed as resistance against “Israel” as a monolith. Nazareth carries biblical and global cultural resonance; it also signals a mixed, complex civic reality. The subtext is clear: if the rockets kill Arab children in a city synonymous with sanctity and everyday life, then claims of principled targeting or liberation collapse into indiscriminate terror.
“Murdered” does additional work. Rockets don’t have intent, but the verb assigns it anyway, translating battlefield action into criminal morality. That choice signals Lantos’s broader political intent: to harden consensus, to justify pressure or retaliation, and to place Hezbollah outside the category of legitimate political actor. Coming from Lantos - a Holocaust survivor turned U.S. congressman deeply invested in human rights rhetoric - the line also asserts a hierarchy of empathy: the victims’ identities are invoked to make moral clarity feel unavoidable.
The most pointed move comes next: “two Israeli Arab children in Nazareth.” This is not incidental detail, it’s a strategic rebuttal. By foregrounding Arab victims inside Israel, Lantos punctures a common justificatory story in which Hezbollah’s violence is framed as resistance against “Israel” as a monolith. Nazareth carries biblical and global cultural resonance; it also signals a mixed, complex civic reality. The subtext is clear: if the rockets kill Arab children in a city synonymous with sanctity and everyday life, then claims of principled targeting or liberation collapse into indiscriminate terror.
“Murdered” does additional work. Rockets don’t have intent, but the verb assigns it anyway, translating battlefield action into criminal morality. That choice signals Lantos’s broader political intent: to harden consensus, to justify pressure or retaliation, and to place Hezbollah outside the category of legitimate political actor. Coming from Lantos - a Holocaust survivor turned U.S. congressman deeply invested in human rights rhetoric - the line also asserts a hierarchy of empathy: the victims’ identities are invoked to make moral clarity feel unavoidable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Tom
Add to List
