"Hiroshima had a profound effect upon me"
About this Quote
A journalist admitting Hiroshima "had a profound effect upon me" is both understatement and provocation. For Wilfred Burchett, the line isn’t a sentimental aside; it’s a claim to authority built on proximity. In 1945 he became the first Western reporter to enter Hiroshima after the bombing, filing accounts that described radiation sickness and mass civilian suffering when official narratives still framed the event as a clean, decisive end to war. “Profound effect” functions as a deliberately modest phrase that smuggles in a larger accusation: if you had seen what I saw, you couldn’t keep repeating the sanitized story.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, it’s personal testimony. Underneath, it’s a rebuke to journalism at a distance and to governments invested in controlling the moral ledger of the atomic age. Burchett’s wording is careful: he doesn’t say “I was horrified” or “it changed my politics,” yet that restraint makes the sentence more damning. It suggests that the reality was so extreme that even the most neutral professional posture was permanently compromised.
Context matters because Burchett’s Hiroshima reporting became inseparable from Cold War suspicion. He was attacked, discredited, and portrayed as a propagandist; later he reported from communist-aligned fronts, further polarizing perceptions of his work. That history turns “profound effect” into a keyhole: it hints at a moment when witnessing shattered not only one city but also his faith in official truth. The subtext is about contamination of another sort: once you’ve stood in the aftermath, objectivity itself feels irradiated.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, it’s personal testimony. Underneath, it’s a rebuke to journalism at a distance and to governments invested in controlling the moral ledger of the atomic age. Burchett’s wording is careful: he doesn’t say “I was horrified” or “it changed my politics,” yet that restraint makes the sentence more damning. It suggests that the reality was so extreme that even the most neutral professional posture was permanently compromised.
Context matters because Burchett’s Hiroshima reporting became inseparable from Cold War suspicion. He was attacked, discredited, and portrayed as a propagandist; later he reported from communist-aligned fronts, further polarizing perceptions of his work. That history turns “profound effect” into a keyhole: it hints at a moment when witnessing shattered not only one city but also his faith in official truth. The subtext is about contamination of another sort: once you’ve stood in the aftermath, objectivity itself feels irradiated.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Wilfred
Add to List

