"History is the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon"
About this Quote
History, Napoleon implies, is less a ledger than a negotiated settlement. The line carries the dry pragmatism of a man who watched regimes rise and collapse on the strength of narratives as much as armies. “Decided to agree upon” is the knife twist: it frames the past not as discovered truth but as a social contract, drafted by whoever has enough power, prestige, or institutional control to make their account stick.
The intent isn’t philosophical hand-wringing; it’s strategic realism. Napoleon understood that legitimacy is retrospective. A coup becomes a “revolution,” an invasion becomes a “liberation,” a retreat becomes a “strategic withdrawal” once the winners write the captions. His own career depended on this alchemy: he posed as the inheritor of the French Revolution’s ideals while consolidating personal rule, and he built a propaganda machine - bulletins, portraits, ceremonies - to fossilize his preferred version of events in public memory.
The subtext is a warning and a boast. Warning: don’t confuse archival survival with moral truth; consensus can be coerced. Boast: I know how consensus is made. Coming from a leader whose legacy ping-pongs between enlightened reformer and imperial aggressor, the quote also preemptively inoculates him against judgment. If history is an agreement, then “posterity” is just another negotiating table, and the fight continues after the last battle - in textbooks, monuments, and the language we use to name what happened.
The intent isn’t philosophical hand-wringing; it’s strategic realism. Napoleon understood that legitimacy is retrospective. A coup becomes a “revolution,” an invasion becomes a “liberation,” a retreat becomes a “strategic withdrawal” once the winners write the captions. His own career depended on this alchemy: he posed as the inheritor of the French Revolution’s ideals while consolidating personal rule, and he built a propaganda machine - bulletins, portraits, ceremonies - to fossilize his preferred version of events in public memory.
The subtext is a warning and a boast. Warning: don’t confuse archival survival with moral truth; consensus can be coerced. Boast: I know how consensus is made. Coming from a leader whose legacy ping-pongs between enlightened reformer and imperial aggressor, the quote also preemptively inoculates him against judgment. If history is an agreement, then “posterity” is just another negotiating table, and the fight continues after the last battle - in textbooks, monuments, and the language we use to name what happened.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Eight Controversial Questions of History (Bob Doti, 2024) modern compilationISBN: 9798891577305 · ID: KCoGEQAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... History is the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon. —Napoleon Bonaparte. Introduction. Was Napoleon right when he wrote, “History is the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon.”? No! We ... Other candidates (1) Eric Hobsbawm (Napoleon Bonaparte) compilation39.0% or though their own descriptions of what they were after were firm and decided they were also o |
More Quotes by Napoleon
Add to List







