"Homo sapiens is the species that invents symbols in which to invest passion and authority, then forgets that symbols are inventions"
About this Quote
Oates lands a quiet indictment inside a clean, almost anthropological sentence: our defining talent is not reason or toolmaking but symbol-making, and our defining danger is amnesia about that fact. “Invents symbols” sounds benign, even creative; “invest passion and authority” is where the heat comes in. We don’t just name things. We load the names with loyalty, fear, desire, sacredness. Then the real pivot: we “forget” the human fingerprints on the whole arrangement. Forgetting turns a made thing into a mandate.
The intent isn’t to sneer at meaning, but to expose how meaning becomes coercive once it hardens into “authority.” Flags, money, borders, gender roles, reputations, nationhood, religion, even “literature” itself: these are collective fictions that can organize life beautifully, until we begin treating them as natural law. Oates’ phrasing implicates everyone, not just ideologues. Passion is part of the trap; the more we feel, the more “real” the symbol seems, and the more vicious we get when it’s threatened.
Context matters: Oates has spent a career anatomizing American violence, celebrity, moral panic, and the stories people tell to justify harm. This line reads like a novelist’s meta-warning: narratives are powerful precisely because they feel inevitable. The subtext is chillingly current: in an era of branding, algorithmic identities, and culture-war totems, forgetting the inventedness of symbols is how politics turns into theology and disagreement becomes heresy. Oates isn’t asking us to live without symbols; she’s asking us to remember they’re ours, so they don’t end up owning us.
The intent isn’t to sneer at meaning, but to expose how meaning becomes coercive once it hardens into “authority.” Flags, money, borders, gender roles, reputations, nationhood, religion, even “literature” itself: these are collective fictions that can organize life beautifully, until we begin treating them as natural law. Oates’ phrasing implicates everyone, not just ideologues. Passion is part of the trap; the more we feel, the more “real” the symbol seems, and the more vicious we get when it’s threatened.
Context matters: Oates has spent a career anatomizing American violence, celebrity, moral panic, and the stories people tell to justify harm. This line reads like a novelist’s meta-warning: narratives are powerful precisely because they feel inevitable. The subtext is chillingly current: in an era of branding, algorithmic identities, and culture-war totems, forgetting the inventedness of symbols is how politics turns into theology and disagreement becomes heresy. Oates isn’t asking us to live without symbols; she’s asking us to remember they’re ours, so they don’t end up owning us.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joyce
Add to List






