"Hope has a good memory, gratitude a bad one"
About this Quote
Hope, Gracian suggests, is a selective archivist: it keeps receipts. It remembers the one time the door opened, the unlikely win, the past mercy that can be repurposed as future proof. Gratitude, by contrast, is painted as willfully amnesiac, a fleeting moral spasm that fades the moment circumstances change. The line lands because it inverts what polite society wants to believe: that gratitude is stable and hope is naive. Gracian, a Jesuit moralist with a courtier's eye for self-interest, aims his cynicism at the social economy beneath virtue.
The intent is not to condemn hope as delusion but to expose its function as psychological strategy. Hope survives by hoarding examples; it needs a remembered precedent to justify continuing. That "good memory" is the engine of resilience, but also a quiet indictment: we hope not because we're brave, but because we can point to a prior exception and insist it might happen again.
Gratitude's "bad memory" cuts sharper. It implies that thankfulness rarely matures into loyalty; it is quickly overwritten by entitlement, new desires, or the next grievance. In Gracian's 17th-century Spain, where patronage and favor were currency, this isn't armchair pessimism. It's field research. The subtext warns the powerful not to confuse momentary thanks for durable allegiance, and it warns the hopeful not to expect moral accounting from the world. Virtue, he implies, is less a bond than a mood.
The intent is not to condemn hope as delusion but to expose its function as psychological strategy. Hope survives by hoarding examples; it needs a remembered precedent to justify continuing. That "good memory" is the engine of resilience, but also a quiet indictment: we hope not because we're brave, but because we can point to a prior exception and insist it might happen again.
Gratitude's "bad memory" cuts sharper. It implies that thankfulness rarely matures into loyalty; it is quickly overwritten by entitlement, new desires, or the next grievance. In Gracian's 17th-century Spain, where patronage and favor were currency, this isn't armchair pessimism. It's field research. The subtext warns the powerful not to confuse momentary thanks for durable allegiance, and it warns the hopeful not to expect moral accounting from the world. Virtue, he implies, is less a bond than a mood.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Baltasar
Add to List












