"How can you tell somebody whose is pursuing happiness that they're somehow not American when that was the very first promise that America made?"
About this Quote
Savage frames “American” less as a passport stamp than as a moral membership card, and he does it with a prosecutor’s question: Who gets to revoke it, and on what grounds? The line hinges on a rhetorical trap. If the nation’s founding brand is “the pursuit of happiness,” then denying someone’s Americanness for pursuing it isn’t merely mean-spirited; it’s a breach of contract. Savage’s intent is to delegitimize gatekeeping by making it look unpatriotic, not just intolerant.
The subtext is sharper than the civics-lesson veneer. “Somehow not American” mimics the slippery language of cultural exclusion: you’re not being deported, just quietly exiled from belonging. Savage is pushing back against a particular American habit: using patriotism as a weapon to police sex, family, and identity while insisting it’s about “values.” His move is to reclaim the founding phrase that’s often treated like decorative parchment and turn it into a live argument.
Context matters because Savage’s public voice is built in the trenches of LGBTQ advocacy and advice-column realism, where moral panics often disguise themselves as tradition. The quote meets that panic on its own turf. Instead of pleading for tolerance, it flips the hierarchy: the person demanding conformity becomes the one out of step with the national story. That’s why it works. It’s not sentimental; it’s strategic. It makes exclusion sound not only cruel, but embarrassingly un-American.
The subtext is sharper than the civics-lesson veneer. “Somehow not American” mimics the slippery language of cultural exclusion: you’re not being deported, just quietly exiled from belonging. Savage is pushing back against a particular American habit: using patriotism as a weapon to police sex, family, and identity while insisting it’s about “values.” His move is to reclaim the founding phrase that’s often treated like decorative parchment and turn it into a live argument.
Context matters because Savage’s public voice is built in the trenches of LGBTQ advocacy and advice-column realism, where moral panics often disguise themselves as tradition. The quote meets that panic on its own turf. Instead of pleading for tolerance, it flips the hierarchy: the person demanding conformity becomes the one out of step with the national story. That’s why it works. It’s not sentimental; it’s strategic. It makes exclusion sound not only cruel, but embarrassingly un-American.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Dan
Add to List
